Last round I did mint chip, and like last time Nick’s has the superior ice cream texture.
For the cookie part of the cookies & cream, Halo Top has a lot of tiny cookie bits, but they‘re too small to really contrast the cream all that much. Nick’s has bigger mix-in chunks, and while the mouth feel is better, they don’t remind of the traditional oreo type cookie (they almost seem more like brownie bits than cookie chunks).
In conclusion I’d say that texture wise, Nick’s wins as per usual, but flavor wise the Halo top is giving more cookies and cream to me, so it slightly edges over.
I’ll call it a tie.
Have you tried either of these? or both? What are your thoughts?
SisterResister
I’m running to the bathroom just looking at these.
Fun fact, one night I ate a whole pint of Halo Top and was so sick I had to call in sick the next morning.
BonScoppinger
I will sh we had these in Germany
Tequila_Sunrise_1022
My stomach is in agony just looking at the pint of Nick’s.
4 Comments
Last round I did mint chip, and like last time Nick’s has the superior ice cream texture.
For the cookie part of the cookies & cream, Halo Top has a lot of tiny cookie bits, but they‘re too small to really contrast the cream all that much. Nick’s has bigger mix-in chunks, and while the mouth feel is better, they don’t remind of the traditional oreo type cookie (they almost seem more like brownie bits than cookie chunks).
In conclusion I’d say that texture wise, Nick’s wins as per usual, but flavor wise the Halo top is giving more cookies and cream to me, so it slightly edges over.
I’ll call it a tie.
Have you tried either of these? or both? What are your thoughts?
I’m running to the bathroom just looking at these.
Fun fact, one night I ate a whole pint of Halo Top and was so sick I had to call in sick the next morning.
I will sh we had these in Germany
My stomach is in agony just looking at the pint of Nick’s.