The basic cheese was spectacular. The definition of light and crispy, and great flavor.

The clam pizza was amazing, even though I generally don't like seafood. Probably the most well rounded pie of the bunch.

The Calabrian Stinger, is one of the best pizzas I've ever tasted. The thin and light crust can't support all the ingredients, which makes for a bit of a mess.

The potato pizza was good, but not on the level of the rest.

by Pyr0technician

9 Comments

  1. portapottytipper

    Was just there a few months ago after having not been for over a decade. It is as outrageously good as I remembered.

    And you killed that order! Throw in a tomato pie and its perfect

  2. TheRealScutFarkus

    We go to all the “big ones” regularly as we live pretty close to New Haven. Sally’s is the unanimous winner for us. That clam pie is a thing of beauty.

  3. MidnightGlitch89

    Looks awesome – great choices! Sally’s is so good 🤤

  4. HerryBalz

    Damn, that cheese pizza looks good! But clams on pizza??

  5. bullfrogftw

    Ah , New Haven, home to the world’s last collection of blind pizza cutting artisans.
    I STG one of those slice cuts is fucking curved

  6. dogsonbubnutt

    man i know everyone raves about this pizza but i don’t think ive ever seen a picture of it that makes me go “this is preferable to dontatos down the street”