Birthday cake at last! 🎂 A somewhat controversial flavor, I’m a lick the batter off the spoon kinda girl, so birthday cake happens to be one of my faves.
Birthday cake oreos, birthday cake protein bars, birthday cake chocolate truffles. Basically anything vaguely vanilla, add some rainbow sprinkles and I’m in.
One of my favorite non diet ice creams is actually Coldstone’s cake batter ice cream (with mix ins of course).
Anyways, I’ll get to it. Usually I prefer Nick’s ice cream texture-wise, but with this flavor they both worked for me, with Halo top possibly edging in for the win. When it comes to that birthday cake flavor, Nick’s was more in your face while Halo Top’s was much more subtle.
Nick’s has more sprinkles, but also more calories. Again, I’m not here to scrutinize the ingredients, so that’s up to you.
In the end I enjoyed them both. If I had that birthday cake craving and saw these side by side in the grocery store, I’d just go for the one on sale.
1 Comment
Birthday cake at last! 🎂 A somewhat controversial flavor, I’m a lick the batter off the spoon kinda girl, so birthday cake happens to be one of my faves.
Birthday cake oreos, birthday cake protein bars, birthday cake chocolate truffles. Basically anything vaguely vanilla, add some rainbow sprinkles and I’m in.
One of my favorite non diet ice creams is actually Coldstone’s cake batter ice cream (with mix ins of course).
Anyways, I’ll get to it. Usually I prefer Nick’s ice cream texture-wise, but with this flavor they both worked for me, with Halo top possibly edging in for the win. When it comes to that birthday cake flavor, Nick’s was more in your face while Halo Top’s was much more subtle.
Nick’s has more sprinkles, but also more calories. Again, I’m not here to scrutinize the ingredients, so that’s up to you.
In the end I enjoyed them both. If I had that birthday cake craving and saw these side by side in the grocery store, I’d just go for the one on sale.
So it seems we have another tie. 🥳