If you’re looking to support a fantastic local business and treat your taste buds at the same time, look no further than Piccolo Italian Market & Deli in Sarasota. This charming, family-run spot tucked away in the Gulf Gate area is a gem for all things Italian-deli-style, with big flavors, warm service, and a strong local appeal. Here’s why it deserves a spotlight in the Shop Local section of the Suncoast Post.
What They Offer
Piccolo serves up a trifecta: delicious made-to-order sandwiches, fresh Italian market goods, and hot entrées you’d be proud to dig into.
Sandwiches galore: From the cold “Godfather” with prosciutto, hot capicola, genoa salami, and fresh mozzarella, to the hot “Frank Sinatra” sandwich with chicken cutlet, prosciutto, roasted peppers, and balsamic glaze, you’ll find hearty, flavorful options that don’t skimp.
Pizza by the slice or pie: They offer thin-crust slices that fans say are reminiscent of New York-style pizza — a nice find here in Florida.
Italian Market & Deli Goods: Think imported cheeses, freshly made Italian sausage, pasta, olive oils, vinegars, deli meats, salads, and more. The shelves are stocked with real Italian specialties alongside deli-counter favorites.
Hot entrees to take home: If you don’t feel like just a sandwich, there are pasta entrées, hot plates, and meals you can bring home for family dinners.
Take-out and convenience: With take-out, market goods, and some dine-in space, you can hit up Piccolo whether it’s a quick lunch stop or a grocery find.
Homemade Pizza Sarasota,Florida
Why Choose Piccolo When You’re Local to Sarasota
There’s something special about keeping it local, and Piccolo stands out as a place where the neighbourhood really benefits.
Authenticity: Many reviewers say the sandwiches, pizza, and deli goods feel like the real deal — as in genuine New York/Italian deli meets Florida sunshine. One reviewer who grew up in Manhattan said they consider Piccolo “without a doubt” the best Italian food in Sarasota.
Family-owned, local vibe: This isn’t a big chain; it’s a spot where the owners and staff know their regulars, care about the food, and show up day after day. That kind of local commitment makes a difference.
Great for all kinds of needs: Whether you’re grabbing a lunch with coworkers, picking up something for dinner, or looking for imported Italian ingredients to cook with, this place covers multiple bases.
Convenience + quality: Located at 6518 Gateway Ave., you’ll find it accessible from the Gulf Gate area of Sarasota. It’s not hidden in some remote industrial zone — it’s part of the local fabric.
Good reputation: With strong reviews across platforms citing flavor, authenticity, and service, it’s a local favorite. One traveler said their pizza was “as close to an authentic slice that I’ve had anywhere outside of the five boroughs.”
How to Get the Most from Your Visit
Arrive with an appetite! Some sandwiches are generously filled and can easily become a full meal.
Don’t skip the market section. Even if you’re just going in for lunch, take a quick browse through the shelves — you might pick up something special like fresh-made sausage or imported olive oil for later.
If you’re picking up for a group or catering a small get-together (friends, office, family), ask about their larger options.
Try something new. If you always go with the sandwiches, maybe grab a slice of pizza or one of their pasta dishes next time.
Go early on weekends since it can get busy at lunch. Even though it’s relaxed and friendly, sometimes the line builds.
In a world where so many meals are rushed and forgettable, Piccolo Italian Market & Deli offers something memorable, local, and delicious. If you’re living on the Suncoast and want to support a business that cares about quality, community, and authenticity — this is one to bookmark.
📍 Contact Details
Piccolo Italian Market & Deli
6518 Gateway Ave., Sarasota, FL 34231
Website: piccolomarket.com
Phone: (941) 923-2202
Hours: Sunday-Monday 10 a.m.–3 p.m.; Tuesday-Saturday 10 a.m.–6 p.m.
Local readers of the Suncoast Post: this is your cue to treat yourself, support local, and taste-test one of Sarasota’s homegrown Italian delights. Buon appetito!
Photos Courtesy of Piccolo Website
Dining and Cooking