This is the biggest variety I’ve ever attempted for my annual holiday cookie box. My favorite is the gingersnap! From top to bottom, left to right:

Brown Butter Pumpkin Oatmeal – https://sallysbakingaddiction.com/brown-butter-pumpkin-oatmeal-cookies/
Chai Almond – https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/recipes/chai-glazed-almond-cookies-recipe
Coconut Crescent – King Arthur Baking School
Matcha Sugar – https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/recipes/matcha-christmas-tree-cookies-recipe
Chocolate Chip – https://sallysbakingaddiction.com/chewy-chocolate-chip-cookies/

Chocolate Crinkle – https://sallysbakingaddiction.com/double-chocolate-crinkle-cookies/
Miso Walnut Chocolate Chunk – Sift
Passion Fruit Shortbread – Desi Bakes
Oreo – Bravetart
Fudge Stripe – Bravetart

Almond Biscotti – https://sallysbakingaddiction.com/chocolate-dipped-almond-biscotti/
Snickerdoodle – https://sallysbakingaddiction.com/soft-thick-snickerdoodles-in-20-minutes/
Gingersnap – https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/recipes/gingersnaps-recipe
Honey Roasted Peanut Butter – Bravetart

Pistachio Crinkle – Sally’s Baking 101
Apricot Thumbprint – 100 Cookies
Strawberry Lemon Drop – Sally’s Baking 101
Cardamom Sugar – Desi Bakes

by motherofsausagedogs

25 Comments

  1. ButterbrainedBadger

    Woaaah that’s super impressive! And there’s such a huge variety too!!

    ( I’ve been trying to get into the art of the Christmas Cookie Box for a couple of years now, and the most I can get through is 2-4 recipes 😀 )

    I’d be super interested in learning more about how you schedule / organize such a production, if you feel like sharing!

  2. Wow this is amazing, such dedication! Such a good job!! 😍😍

  3. scoutswalker

    Your organization is spectacular and your quality of your ingredients as well! I am super picky about eating food from other people’s kitchens,but from your pictures I can see you are particular about how things get done and to me that means all the way down to a clean space, clean hands. Way to go!!!!

  4. OrneryToo

    Whoa! You are a Cookie Master!
    Christmas sweets!!!
    I (62F) grew up baking special treats every year and continue the tradition of gifting baked goods The hubs’ crew has already mentioned cookie boxes past. Next week is “bake week”.

  5. whooptydo72

    They’re so gorgeous, great selection of different flavours, and your organisation skills are so satisfying to witness. Thanks for sharing it. I like the table or bench top in all the photos too, looks like such a nice space to bake in!! Merry Merry Christmas to you 🙂

  6. Smorsdoeuvres

    OMG they’re gorgeous!! Thank you for sharing your recipes! Happy holidays to you and yours!!

  7. brinkinz123

    This is seriously so impressive! There’s such variety (they all look delicious) and the fact that you did them all in a weekend is amazing. I always get so tired after the fourth or fifth cookie haha

  8. According-Two-297

    They look like floor cookies in the first image 🤪. I’d eat all of them off the floor too 🥰

  9. Apex_Herbivore

    Stupid question here, but I am planning on doing this or similar – how long do these last?

    Its still like 2 weeks until xmas day and i might not see some of my fam until later – so like, are the special recipies or something?

    I keep seeing them when my plan was to make them way way close to the date.

  10. Conscious_Leg_561

    I’m impressed! Do you make these for family and friends or? I can wait to start making mine next week, im going to drop some boxes off at our local fire dept 😁🥰🙌

  11. So many different spices going on here, it’s eye opening! I’ve never thought of chai, miso, passionfruit, or cardamom in cookies; but I’m all for it!

    This brings back old memories where I did 15 cookies for the holidays…I had a whole excel spreadsheet of ingredients, volume, and batches. I’d sit there and math it all out on Excel and know how much I’d need to buy. I was mighty proud of myself figuring that all out.

    It’s a lot of work, but the results are always amazing and can beat any store bought gift!

  12. Lanky_Salt_5865

    This is incredibly impressive… and motivating! Of the cookies you made which did you personally like the most?

  13. chiginger

    Extremely impressive! I have 3 of 12 left to make up, but ran out of room in my freezer for the doughs. Next weekend my oven is going to be working overtime.

  14. theflyestunicorn

    One, this is amazing!!!
    Two, thank you for listing out which books the recipes came from. I was for sure coming to ask about the Strawberry Lemon + Chai Almond lol.

  15. Aggressive-Quail6602

    I just want to say, I appreciate all these photos! I know they added more time to your project but they were worth it!

  16. littledragon912

    Omg the dedication is so real! They all look so delicious!!!