Which bottle would you crack for a new years dinner? Menu is little neck clams, lamb chops with mint sauce, risotto with broccolini, and carrots with goat cheese. Thoughts?
by Disastrous-Zebra9882
21 Comments
deeznutzz3469
I’ll leave it to the experts but just want to give the love for the finger lakes
meowdith427
Chimney rock all the way. It’s an elegant Napa wine versus some of these others which can throw a punch…this will probably complement your risotto best.
I’d suggest starting with a nice white (Chablis!) for the clams and risotto then moving onto the chimney rock.
Happy new year, enjoy!!
marrypoppins344
Inglewood or chimney but both are going to be great
Business-Writer-7874
I’d open that chimney rock. Should be good.
highplainsdrifter6
In this lineup, Absolutely no on the Bully Hill. Feel bad hating on Fingerlakes. Label is beautiful though. I’d go rubicon or chimney rock all day.
JuanOffhue
Chimney Rock, then Palermo for the second bottle (if you don’t mind crashing out before the ball drops).
HotSarcasm
Palermo for me.
bum_stabber
#unfriendorinswift
Royal-Kiwi9050
Chimney Rock would be my pick. So layered and nuanced.
berXrup
Rubicon, you’ll be happy
ExaminationFancy
Chimney Rock for me.
I just had a 2015 Inglenook Rubicon a few weeks ago. It was OK, but it wasn’t worth the price I paid. I was underwhelmed.
Beatrice1494
Only kids make choices; I’ll drink it all. Alright, lol.
brooklynguitarguy
Never Bully Hill unless the guests don’t like fine wine, then that and secretly pour Chimney Rock for the people who do.
bii345
I’d get after that rubicon 🙂
ExternalClimate3536
This meal is screaming for CA Pinot, not Cab.
SavedByThe1990s
im a chimney rock member so theyre always be on my list. but i do also love duckhorn. the artemis is pretty good too
MathematicianLast650
Why is Bully Hill in there?!?
UnobviousDiver
I didn’t have the same selection but I went with Artemis. A bit fruitier than I like but paired well with wagyu and mushrooms. Happy new year!!
JCFroggie
It’s NY! Open them all starting with Artemis 😉
Redditholio
Chimney Rock. Inglenook as runner-up.
Disastrous-Zebra9882
THE PEOPLE HAVE SPOKEN – Chimney Rock it is! Followed by Artemis (will save Inglenook). Shame no one appreciates the Napa Valley of the east. Bully Hill will be place on the kids table. Thank you all, and happy new year!
21 Comments
I’ll leave it to the experts but just want to give the love for the finger lakes
Chimney rock all the way. It’s an elegant Napa wine versus some of these others which can throw a punch…this will probably complement your risotto best.
I’d suggest starting with a nice white (Chablis!) for the clams and risotto then moving onto the chimney rock.
Happy new year, enjoy!!
Inglewood or chimney but both are going to be great
I’d open that chimney rock. Should be good.
In this lineup, Absolutely no on the Bully Hill. Feel bad hating on Fingerlakes. Label is beautiful though.
I’d go rubicon or chimney rock all day.
Chimney Rock, then Palermo for the second bottle (if you don’t mind crashing out before the ball drops).
Palermo for me.
#unfriendorinswift
Chimney Rock would be my pick. So layered and nuanced.
Rubicon, you’ll be happy
Chimney Rock for me.
I just had a 2015 Inglenook Rubicon a few weeks ago. It was OK, but it wasn’t worth the price I paid. I was underwhelmed.
Only kids make choices; I’ll drink it all. Alright, lol.
Never Bully Hill unless the guests don’t like fine wine, then that and secretly pour Chimney Rock for the people who do.
I’d get after that rubicon 🙂
This meal is screaming for CA Pinot, not Cab.
im a chimney rock member so theyre always be on my list. but i do also love duckhorn. the artemis is pretty good too
Why is Bully Hill in there?!?
I didn’t have the same selection but I went with Artemis. A bit fruitier than I like but paired well with wagyu and mushrooms.
Happy new year!!
It’s NY! Open them all starting with Artemis 😉
Chimney Rock. Inglenook as runner-up.
THE PEOPLE HAVE SPOKEN – Chimney Rock it is! Followed by Artemis (will save Inglenook). Shame no one appreciates the Napa Valley of the east. Bully Hill will be place on the kids table. Thank you all, and happy new year!