XXXtra hot habanero reigns supreme. It is quite spicy but not unmanageable, and has amazing flavor. The best out of the bunch.
Grilled pineapple & habanero is my next favorite. The least spicy out of everything, but has very good flavor and you can really taste the pineapple.
Black label reserve has a good kick and smokiness. A better and bolder flavor than green & red habanero.
4 & 5. Green & red habanero are great all rounders. Good spice, but they don’t taste that different to me and they could go with anything.
6 & 7. Marisquera black & red. I didn’t realize they are meant to go on seafood, but they still tasted fine and weren’t really spicy to me.
Chiltepin habanero had a sharper flavor to it. Decent spice, and wasn’t crazy about it but I will definitely try it again.
Ghost pepper habanero didn’t have good flavor and just tasted like ghost pepper extract. Oddly it wasn’t as spicy as the xxxtra hot habanero even though it’s supposed to be the spiciest.
Caribbean habanero tasted quite sharp and was spicy, (not to the level of the xxxtra hot habanero) but I just wasn’t a fan of the flavor profile. I think they tried to get a jerk flavor in there but it just wasn’t working.
11, 12, 13. I am curious to try coffee habanero but don’t know if I want to commit to a whole bottle of it. I’ll probably skip the jalapeno and chipotle since they aren’t supposed to be very spicy.
by saltyclam13345
27 Comments
I’d bump Caribbean up to S and pineapple down to C (just too sweet for me) but otherwise agree
I haven’t tried most but black label over green and red is wild!
Have t tried the pineapple one. But overall I agree.
Caribbean and Black Label Reserve should be “S” Tier
All that matters is XXXtra hot is number 1
I’ve found quite a few people can’t stand the taste of the xxxtra hot one. I didn’t mind it but it’s not my favorite. I would say green is my number one
The black label is S-tier for me because I make a lot of jambalaya. The smoky heat goes super well with anything cajun.
Back Label Reserve is F tier for me. I’d put Chiltepin and Caribbean on A tier. The XXX is the best though.
XXX deserves that spot
I sooo wish the green habanero sauce was like 3x hotter 😩
The jalapeno is spicier than one would expect; the chipotle is addictively delicious.
Gotta respect the Mayan Recipe
I would agree with this chart.
Xxx is the GOAT
It’s not very hot, but the Chipotle is delicious.
Caribbean A tier for sure.
Honestly, my first full agreement
Team Red here!
Here’s a heresy, just for the lols: black label tastes more fishy than it does smoky and I don’t care for it.
Caribbean in D tier is illegal
Xxxxtra got is my favourite bottled hot sauce of all time. I’m gonna look out for their pineapple habanero.
I was about to yell at you jalapeno not being a C for middle ground until I read the title for bottom tier
I definitely wanna try the grilled pineapple one now
Agreed on #1 for sure.
Xxxtra and carribean in s tier for me.
Me personally, I’d bump that black label way down and also bump the green boi up
Caribbean gotta be S tier
Black label is gross. Definitely an acquired taste.