Carbonara is where pasta journey began for me. Here's how I do it:

Ingredients: Guanciale, spaghetti, pecorino, eggs, black pepper, salt

  1. Grill guanciale. Once grilled enough (cripy), put some aside for plating later and leave oil in the pan

  2. Mix eggs, pecorino, and black pepper

  3. Add pasta 2 minutes before al dente into the pan with guanciale oil, stir. Add some pasta water

  4. Put the stainless bowl with the sauce on top of the pasta water pan at low heat and toss pasta mixed with guanciale oil into it. Then stir vigorously (this helps with not scrambling the egg mix the way I understand). Add some pasta water when sauce is almost absorbed

  5. Remove from the heat and final mantecatura

  6. Plate the finished pasta and put guanciale back on with more pecorino and black pepper

by Neyrok37

6 Comments

  1. christo749

    Looks really good. Did the sauce adhere to the pasta?

  2. fabulousmarco

    It looks good, but it seems to me from the first and last pictures that the sauce is a bit too liquid. Or maybe there is just too much. The background is blurry so it’s hard to tell.

    I would avoid using the pasta water unless you absolutely need to. The egg and pecorino mixture alone should give you the correct texture.

    Also, this is purely a matter of preference but I recommend short pasta instead of spaghetti with carbonara. My experience with spaghetti is that the guanciale will make its way down to the bottom of the bowl as you eat the pasta, while if you use Tortiglioni or Mezze Maniche or something of the sort it will get trapped inside.

  3. Inspectadreck

    Looks great apart from the runny sauce. There are a few ways to deal with this. Dont add any pasta water, the pasta water thats on the noodles is enough. The eggs have enough water.

    When doing the waterbath method you chose its important to be very Patient, because the sauce takes for ever to thicken that way. But it can also give the best result.

    I Prefer to finish in the warm pan for that reason. Its a lot quicker, especially when doing more than one Portion. If the pan is off the heat for a Minute the eggs shouldnt scramble at all. It can also be heated gently after the fact to thicken the sauce even more, in the smallest burner, lowest setting.

  4. rb56redditor

    Looks good, a bit runny as others have said. I just had carbonara at roscioli in Rome. Delicious, unfortunately I’ll never be able to make it a home again, it will never live up to that.

  5. Looks better than most of the other posts to this sub. Just a bit runny as others have mentioned, but you’re 95% of the way there.

  6. alexpazza

    Did you use the whole egg or just the yolk ?