If you had to pick six of these flavors, which ones would you choose?
by ImaginationOk8645
14 Comments
PatrickCoughATon
Caramel Pecan Sticky buns sounds like a can’t miss
MF-DOOM-88
Paying with klarna???
madisonguy76
From the ones I’ve tried, Savannah Buttermint (no. 1 Jeni’s overall), Goat Cheese with Red Cherries, Tropical Bloom and Strawberry Buttermilk I would happily buy again. Queen Charlotte would be a maybe (it was good, but they have better flavors), then flip a coin between Banana Pudding and Peppermint Patty. They were both fine, but I wouldn’t get again. Both are coconut base, but you taste it much more in the banana flavor.
I didn’t care for pineapple upside down cake (too sour for me) but know others really like it. Sticky Buns was by the far worst Jeni’s I ever got. I might have had a bad batch, but no sticky, no caramel, no buns, just nuts.
DodoAirlinesIntern
My pick six would be out of what you shortlisted: Earl Grey because I’m curious Queen Charlotte because it’s pretty good (not as good as wedding cake though) House Coffee Pineapple Upside down Cake Peppermint Patty Goat Cheese
If it were me, I’d swap out a goat cheese for a bay leaf cheesecake though.
Responsible-Head-936
I loooove their dairy free as someone not dairy free. I know you already got a thumbs down to the caramel sticky bun but I am thumbsing it up
-PrincessPumpkin-
Watermelon taffy tasted like greek yogurt to me… I would not purchase that one ever again.
Affectionate_Ad722
I just placed an order yesterday for two each of flavors I can’t get locally: the two Bridgerton, house coffee, strawberry buttermilk, and goat cheese.
Glittering_Nobody402
I would first check my local store to ensure I can’t just get any of these flavors locally for much cheaper ($8-10, typically, $5 on sale). Minnesota has Whole Foods and they have a huge selection, but also discount often. Even my Coborns carries some, if not Target (the only thing I buy from Target).
What I am most looking forward to is Goat cheese/cherries. I also had both Bridgerton flavors in my cart as well as Boston Cream Pie, Buttermilk and Lemon/Blueberry. I closed my browser.
Even with free shipping, I’m still taking mt chances with the stores. But I tend to really only buy when on sale.
DeltaFlyer0525
Do you have a Target to get the watermelon flavor? It’s half that price in stores, it’s on sale currently in my area not sure it’s the same nationwide though.
bihighguy420
Have the strawberry buttermilk in my freezer, delicious!
ImaginationOk8645
Update: I ordered Savannah buttermint, pineapple upside down cake, watermelon taffy, strawberry, tropical bloom, and goat cheese with cherries! So excited to try! I’ve been a fan of of jenis for a few years and these flavors are never available at my local stores so the free shipping finally had me hit order!
Mcemi
ATX local here! The two Bridgerton flavors are 💯. Savannah Butttermint is the best mint chip ice cream I’ve ever had. Jeni’s Brown Butter Almond Brittle is also S-tier. (imagine butter pecan but elevated to the gods)
une_noisette
I love the goat cheese cherry. I didn’t like the earl gray- I think it had too many other flavors competing with the earl gray flavor.
une_noisette
If you haven’t tried it, the sweet cream biscuits with peach jam is really good.
14 Comments
Caramel Pecan Sticky buns sounds like a can’t miss
Paying with klarna???
From the ones I’ve tried, Savannah Buttermint (no. 1 Jeni’s overall), Goat Cheese with Red Cherries, Tropical Bloom and Strawberry Buttermilk I would happily buy again. Queen Charlotte would be a maybe (it was good, but they have better flavors), then flip a coin between Banana Pudding and Peppermint Patty. They were both fine, but I wouldn’t get again. Both are coconut base, but you taste it much more in the banana flavor.
I didn’t care for pineapple upside down cake (too sour for me) but know others really like it. Sticky Buns was by the far worst Jeni’s I ever got. I might have had a bad batch, but no sticky, no caramel, no buns, just nuts.
My pick six would be out of what you shortlisted:
Earl Grey because I’m curious
Queen Charlotte because it’s pretty good (not as good as wedding cake though)
House Coffee
Pineapple Upside down Cake
Peppermint Patty
Goat Cheese
If it were me, I’d swap out a goat cheese for a bay leaf cheesecake though.
I loooove their dairy free as someone not dairy free. I know you already got a thumbs down to the caramel sticky bun but I am thumbsing it up
Watermelon taffy tasted like greek yogurt to me… I would not purchase that one ever again.
I just placed an order yesterday for two each of flavors I can’t get locally: the two Bridgerton, house coffee, strawberry buttermilk, and goat cheese.
I would first check my local store to ensure I can’t just get any of these flavors locally for much cheaper ($8-10, typically, $5 on sale). Minnesota has Whole Foods and they have a huge selection, but also discount often. Even my Coborns carries some, if not Target (the only thing I buy from Target).
What I am most looking forward to is Goat cheese/cherries. I also had both Bridgerton flavors in my cart as well as Boston Cream Pie, Buttermilk and Lemon/Blueberry. I closed my browser.
Even with free shipping, I’m still taking mt chances with the stores. But I tend to really only buy when on sale.
Do you have a Target to get the watermelon flavor? It’s half that price in stores, it’s on sale currently in my area not sure it’s the same nationwide though.
Have the strawberry buttermilk in my freezer, delicious!
Update: I ordered Savannah buttermint, pineapple upside down cake, watermelon taffy, strawberry, tropical bloom, and goat cheese with cherries! So excited to try! I’ve been a fan of of jenis for a few years and these flavors are never available at my local stores so the free shipping finally had me hit order!
ATX local here!
The two Bridgerton flavors are 💯.
Savannah Butttermint is the best mint chip ice cream I’ve ever had.
Jeni’s Brown Butter Almond Brittle is also S-tier. (imagine butter pecan but elevated to the gods)
I love the goat cheese cherry. I didn’t like the earl gray- I think it had too many other flavors competing with the earl gray flavor.
If you haven’t tried it, the sweet cream biscuits with peach jam is really good.