So, similar to another post from earlier, I had a coworker who brought in pints from Van Leeuwen for their birthday. I was so happy to see the birthday cake flavor because it’s one I’ve wanted to try for a while. I give it an 8/10, I’m not usually someone who likes really sweet things but, this I would grab this again if I was in the mood for it. The icing was a bit too sweet for me (just a bit). The only thing I wish were different was that instead of the cookies, it had crunchies, like the Carvel Ice Cream cake.

by drmohanstears

8 Comments

  1. smileyfacegauges

    HOOOOOOooooo that looks really really good 👀

  2. glimmerofhopetarot

    Crunchies would be so good. Cookies are an odd choice for ice cream cake flavor. I love their ice cream though

  3. Calm_Discipline_9218

    I’ll be looking for this one! It sounds yummy!

  4. Necessary-Jeweler-17

    Blue ice cream!? Damnit I wish I still ate sugar 😭

  5. tachycardicIVu

    I mentioned this on the other recent post: yes the icing is sweet and it has this weird flavor that’s not offputting but reminds me of the waxy candles on a cake like after they’ve dripped a bit and either the wax gets on the cake or you lick the candles after removing them from the cake. It’s a weirdly nostalgic combination that I love. I do wish the icing were a bit softer like a swirl so I could divvy it up more easily; I sometimes have to chip away at it to get just a small piece in each bite. But it’s one of my favorite ice creams of all time and I will be devastated if they ever discontinue it.

  6. PunnyPrinter

    Lots of people don’t like this one but I love it.