Was really excited for this. Unfortunately, the cookie pieces were sparse, small, and I didn't get any notes of salt to compliment the sweetnees. Yes the base is quality, but essentially this was a chocolate chip ice cream with minimal crunchy cookie pieces. Give me B&J Milk and Cookies every time over this. 6/10
by iATEthat84
3 Comments
Yeah I didnt rate it either. The coffee toffee almond was meh too. Out of the new ones id say Peanut Brittle is best!
This ice cream seems to be pretty polarizing on this sub! I’ve tried it, and I think it’s a good ice cream and well balanced, but I agree with you that I’d like a little bigger cookie pieces. The base is good. I think I gave it about an 8 though.
I really liked this one! I have a pint in the freezer right now actually. I thought it was a nice change of pace to have actual cookies instead of dough, but I did have this one before I tried Milk & Cookies for the first time. Milk & Cookies is hard to beat!