Do you agree with this ranking?

by Gluttonforcrime

36 Comments

  1. Tostig_Thungerfart

    Welsh Rarebit isn’t a sandwich.

    Where’s the sausage butty, chip butty, crisp sarnie, and the fish finger sarnie? Ham & cheese toastie?

  2. Fat-Northerner

    Total bullshit, cucumber sandwich is on there and cheese and pickle is not? Also Welsh rarebit is not a sandwich. The legit list should read as follows:

    1. Bacon butty

    2. Cheese and pickle

    3. Ham and mustard

    4. Wigan kebab

    5. Egg butty

  3. Anaksanamune

    A basic cucumber sandwich shouldn’t make it into the top 50, let alone the top 5…

  4. Cucumber over any sandwich with cheese? (Rarebit doesn’t count) Yeah no.

  5. Over_Entertainer8049

    I love a cucumber sandwich with salad cream even better with a bit of cheese

  6. stickle-brick

    1. Christmas sandwich!
    2. Roast beef and horse sauce
    3. Salad sandwich
    4. Ham and cucumber
    5. Chicken, sweetcorn and mayo

  7. Welsh493

    Rarebit isn’t a sandwich. Also, in my own personal opinion, cucumber can get in the bin, stick of dirty water tasting misery.

  8. MedievalFolkDance

    I’m skeptical. Not one mention of adding crisps.

  9. NoPaleontologist1355

    A fucking cucumber sandwich. Get in the bin

  10. Pretty sure BLT is American. Chip butty, fish finger and cheese & pickle are all classics sandwiches though.

  11. woodpecker_juice

    no way.
    1. Boxing Day Butty – warm ciabatta stuffed with hot turkey in gravy, sausage stuffing, bread sauce, and a touch of cranberry sauce
    2. Fish goujon sarnie – nice white bread, crispy goujons, homemade tartare sauce
    3. Smoked salmon & cream cheese on a toasted sesame bagel
    4. lamb kebabs with plenty of garlic mayo and pickled peppers
    5. Rare steak sandwich with pickled onions, aioli, and lightly dressed rocket

    Add to the list a nice cheddar & small chunk branstons toastie, crisp butties, chip butties, king prawn marie rose sandos with smoked salmon, lobster rolls, chicken mayo sarnies, honey roast ham on good baguette with salty butter and cornichons… is a sausage roll a sandwich??? is a cheeseburger? welsh rarebit certainly isn’t…

  12. stormtrooperbob321

    Corned Beef, Horseradish, and Red onion is the best sandwich.

  13. Paulstan67

    I ran a cafe/sandwich shop for 10 years,

    The running order was.

    1 bacon (with/without egg)
    2 sausage (w/w egg)
    3 tuna mayo (w/w cucumber)
    4 ham (w/w salad)
    5 chicken and stuffing
    6 prawn marie rose sauce.

    Adding cheese to any of these was also popular.

  14. Kelski94

    Chicken and bacon club sandwich should be 1, followed by sausage butty, then a chip butty, then a bacon butty. That’s it. That’s the list.

  15. Illustrious_Hat_9177

    1 and 2, yes. Can be interchangeable as both are perfect.

    Welsh rarebit is lovely but not a sandwich.

    Egg and cress? Bland bland bland. Egg mayo (with crispy bacon) though, yes.

    Cucumber sandwich. In the flipping bin.

  16. Flatulent_Weasel

    No. Egg n cress and cucumber wouldn’t even be in my top 20.

  17. BetterSupermarket430

    Where the fuck is cheese & pickle?

  18. time_on_target

    Err.. no sausage bap, no cheese n pickle, no chip butty

  19. grafeisen203

    Not even close.

    Bacon sausage and egg, sure, but bacon butty on its own is pretty mid.

    No tuna mayo.

    No chicken and bacon.

    No cheese and onion.

    No coronation chicken.

  20. PerspectiveNo1519

    Who the hell has cucumber sandwiches and egg and cress sandwiches. Heathens

  21. sinchigh

    Cucumber can fuck off. No business even being a sandwich. What about cheese and pickle. If you’re going all the way stick a bit of ham in it

  22. Objective_Beyond_897

    Cucumber Sandwich… Is that even a thing.
    Ploughman’s, sausage and mustard. Hot beef and horseradish

  23. 199Simon199

    Eggs bacon sausage WTF cucumber sandwich lmao

  24. orkboss12

    Anyone who voted cucumber sandwich need to be killed for heresy

  25. kingofthepews

    I’m Welsh so take pride in our rarebit. But it doesn’t belong on this list at all.

  26. Calm_est

    Ah yes.. I forgot absolutely nothing comes between 4 and mouth rot 5.

  27. Goldcrest25

    Hogwash. Since when are cucumber sandwiches better than coronation chicken? 🤨

  28. Dalegalitarian

    Taste Atlas is a dog shite site. Don’t trust a single thing they say

  29. PassiveChemistry

    Why is cucumber sandwich anywhere even *near* this list?

  30. Taste Atlas is a nonsense. They list English breakfast at 81 in their top 100 breakfasts.

Write A Comment