$21 a dozen now?! I don’t order very often but this seems like a big jump from what I remember, even taking in to account standard restaurant inflation. Does anyone have their price history on hand? When did this happen? Add in their $6 delivery fee + tax & a fair tip and you’re looking at $35 for a dozen cookies? Phew. I’ll be baking my own, tyvm. Potentially on my back patio where the temp is oven ready.
by CassieDAnn
31 Comments
Used to work there for several years, was surprised that people would pay so much for cookies!
Yeah, that’s insane. I know they were $18 semi-recently, which already felt really steep for the size of their cookies.
I only ever order when they have a 50% off promo code floating around. It pops up surprisingly often
Crumble cookie is $40.99 per a dozen
There are two types of people ordering this: people giving gifts who are ordering last minute that don’t care about price, and then those who are willing to pay to avoid the shame of the checkout line at HEB with a box of cookies. There is no one else. Tiff’s treats aren’t for you 😂
I’ve had a few friends who worked in corporate at Tiff’s. They refuse to support Tiff’s at all now.
The owners are not great people, unfortunately, but they’ve built a good brand for Austin.
Just order them on Too Good To Go and pick them up yourself, if you don’t care about what flavor you get it’s like six bucks.
Milk and Cookies is more expensive but exponentially better.
https://www.sweetpeaspicnicsupply.com/shop This is my go-to these days for cookie delivery. The order won’t be fulfilled as quickly as Tiff’s, but way better and ever so slightly cheaper.
Grocery store bakery cookies are far better than Tiff’s
Whenever I see one of Tiff’s Treats cars I have to wonder how many cookies do you have to sell to pay that car off? It must be working, they’ve been around for years.
Tiffs isn’t even good. Go to H‑E‑B or any bakery for tasty cookies. Hell, McDonald’s has a tote of 13 for like 5 bucks and they’re warm and chewy.
Don’t forget about Tiff’s unionbusting.
This is probably not helpful, but I just found an order confirmation in my email from 2017, in which I’d ordered two dozen cookies for delivery for $28. I have another receipt from 2011, in which I paid $17.50 for two dozen cookies (pickup).
They’re good, but not that good. Toll house straight from the oven are better.
Sent my mom some to Michigan. It was $70, she had to bake them herself, and they got the order wrong. Also, stopped ordering from them because the cookies were always stuck together and would break when we tried to get them apart.
Earliest capture on wayback machine is from 2004. Cookies were $6.75/dozen.
Tiffs… The most over rated cookies ever..
. But once you borrowed 50 million dollars you better get the money back somehow
For that price I better “fully-sweet” chocolate chips.
Welcome to fuckin Austin 2023. It’s the cost of business. If you don’t like it, move away. I just did.
How big are the cookies? $1.75 a cookie isn’t bad if they’re decently sized. Honestly any time I walk into a bakery or shop the cookies cost more than that.
$6 delivery fee and tip is on you.
This is why I now make my own cookies.
I bought the dough in a tube from the store, baked it and ate it right after they were done in the oven and they tasted better than tiffs treats
I think they are on the Too Good to Go App aren’t they?
Just make your own, if you’re too lazy to do that then pay the money.
Tiffs was good 15 years ago. Now it sucks. Too many better cookie options now.
Tiffs is overrated. Make them at home in less time. My 3yr old makes better cookies.
13/dz 2016; 15 2017; 16 2019; 19 March 2022; 20 June 2022
I’ve heard multiple ex employees say it’s just the recipe from the crisco container. Lol
They are warm cookies delivered to wherever you want, I don’t know why anybody would think that wouldn’t cost you.
I’m here to bust up the reddit hater party to say that IMO Tiff’s still rocks. They may not be AS great and more expensive than when they started (I’m an amazing salesperson) but they still rock. Most of the comparative places aren’t nearly as good and just as expensive. So rather than breaking down a local company about how crummy they are let’s just be happy that a decent local company still exists. Don’t order them if you don’t want, but they are there if you need or want them.