In a fan-favorite episode, Dexter Morgan takes a break from his close-up, slow-motion morning routine to kill a friend in need. But he can’t saran-wrap her to a table and scalpel her cheek like any other Monday, he’s gotta be nice about it, so he finds the best key lime pie in Miami and pumps it full of night-night juice. I’ve heard of humble pie but this is ridiculous! Sorry.

Recipe: https://www.bingingwithbabish.com/recipes/dexter-key-lime-pie

Music: “A Beautiful Life” by Broke for Free

My playlist of preferred cooking tunes, Bangers with Babish!
https://spoti.fi/2TYXmiY

Binging With Babish Website: http://bit.ly/BingingBabishWebsite
Basics With Babish Website: http://bit.ly/BasicsWithBabishWebsite
Patreon: http://bit.ly/BingingPatreon
Instagram: http://bit.ly/BabishInstagram
Facebook: http://bit.ly/BabishFacebook
Twitter: http://bit.ly/BabishTwitter

48 Comments

  1. Would YOU mercy-kill renowned character actress Margot Martindale if she asked you to, despite it going against your serial killer code, even though euthanasia and palliative treatment are an imperative part of end-of-life care, and your playing judge/jury/executioner with the general populace is arguably much more morally ambiguous? Shout it out in the comments!

  2. Funny, I am binging Dexter these days in anticipation for the new series coming out. I'm at the part about the perfect key lime pie, and thought, "Did Babish do an episode of this recipe?" and well here I am now watching this lol

  3. Just… very silly question:
    What happens if you do NOT bake the crust before putting the custard on it and instead bake the entire thing for close to 40 minutes (because that is what I did and I shudder to think what horrible abomination this cake might have become)

  4. "You were right about my brother..and I killed him." I just watched this episode 7 hours ago. Really hit me hard.

  5. Made this for super bowl and everyone loved it! Thanks for the awesome video. Definitely making it again.

  6. The traditional technique is to put the graham crackers in a ziploc bag and smack it against the side of the house and sidewalk in an adolescent fury. It should sound like sporadic gunfire.

  7. LOL I was just watching Dexter again and I was at the part of the KEY LIME PIE, and I was curious so here I am.😁 It looks Delicious! Gonna give it a go…😋

  8. If you wanna make a perfect Key Lime Pie with REAL Key Limes, Follow me! 15-20 of my limes make half cup!

  9. You could do segmented key lime slices then they would be edible! or bits of candied key lime peels!

    I was watching this video for research purposes.
    Husband requested this or banoffee is for his birthday. my baking skills are loading

  10. Is it blasphemy that I want to make this exact recipe, minus the Sodium Pentothal, I'm trying to cut cut down on my salt intake, but with Mandarins instead of Keylimes ? ? ?

  11. Lo irónico es que aquí solo tengo limas y limones pues ésas no los pruebo en un año xd

  12. A pharmacist took this video seriously and thought those two chemicals were actually part of the recipe…

Write A Comment