My Top Grandma Slices in NYC. What am I missing out on?
1. Vito’s Ices & Slices
2. Gravesend Pizza (Yes, it’s more of an upside-down, I know)
3. Luigi’s in South Slope
4. Unregular Pizza
5. Nolita Pizza
6. Mark’s (Red Hook)
What are other spots I should check out?
by CuteWolves
41 Comments
SamizdatGuy
Luigi’s grandma vodka slice kills
herseyhawkins33
Marinara is excellent, has a few locations in Manhattan
SadCombination7535
Mama’s too makes a mean square
jgold1975
Spumoni Gardens
DiRub
Best pizza’s grandma is legit – Rosa’s grandma is classic and good
friendlyNYCguy
Umbertos of NHP home and original of the grandma Queens Nassau border
pumper911
Love Best Pizza’s Grandma
sunnym5141
Mimi’s in the UES
Rob-Loring
Philomenas in sunnyside Roma pizza in Manhattan (6th Ave and 36 st)
hagvul
I always loved the Williamsburg pizza grandma slice
pra_vda
MO’s general
poopmast
I would check out Pizza Suprema if you’re going to Vitos
SomeDrillingImplied
Grandma pizza is the best type of pizza, IMO.
Plastic_Profile4887
L&B is not a grandma slice, people
carpy22
Underground Pizza in the Financial District’s vodka grandma slice.
housepalace
Freddie Prinze Paulie Gee’s slice shop
Outrageous-Animal-15
Nino’s in bay ridge
Hopeful-Mirror1664
Believe it or not there is this little pizza joint on Middletown Town Road in the Bronx called Franks Pizza. They make an outstanding Grandmas Pie.
Dontbeacreper
I like upside grandma
crappergoons
Russ on Manhattan ave in Greenpoint
milkchocolatesheikh
Mimi’s ues goated
syrix1
Louie’s Pizza in Elmhurst
cas__94
Hit up corner slice and fini
Sad_Hungry
Many of the best have been mentioned but I’ll add some sleepers :
Brother’s pizza in Staten does a pretty good one
DaVinci on 18th Ave in Brooklyn (but the Sicilian is better )
Not technically a grandma but the Freddie Prinze slice at Paulie Gees slice shop I really enjoy because of the sesame seeds on the bottom
NY Pizza Suprema is respectable
A divisive pick but I like Rizzos
And even though not exactly grandma the squares at mamas too I think are quality
Amazing-Objective232
Franks pizza Middletown Rd, Bronx, NY
thenumbersthenumbers
DaNonna Rosa… trust
JayMoots
Bleecker Street. Their most famous slice is the Nonna Maria, which is Grandma toppings on a round pie. But they also do a traditional square Grandma which is just as good.
phunkytime
Vito’s 😍
cumberlandbluez
Fazio’s
poboy212
F&F in Carroll Gardens has a solid one
SDtheGhostt
Sals on wyckoff ave in bushwick. Never makes a list but that slice is crack!!
randomlycorduroy
Luna Pizza
Conscious_Ad3458
House of Pizza and Calzone in Cobble Hill!
novakid
Village square
shaheertheone
Mama’s too
clowns_must_stand
Lo Duca in Newkirk Plaza, Ditmas Park, Brooklyn
jeremiadOtiose
Salvos on the UES is excellent.
jpkmets
Gotham Pizza York Ave and 76 is superb.
Domoromoz
The folks at r/pizza would have a shit fit if they knew people on here confusing grandma pies with Sicilian pizza…
oakman26
Pepperoni grandma at “Rome to Brooklyn” near Grand st (L)
41 Comments
Luigi’s grandma vodka slice kills
Marinara is excellent, has a few locations in Manhattan
Mama’s too makes a mean square
Spumoni Gardens
Best pizza’s grandma is legit – Rosa’s grandma is classic and good
Umbertos of NHP
home and original of the grandma
Queens Nassau border
Love Best Pizza’s Grandma
Mimi’s in the UES
Philomenas in sunnyside
Roma pizza in Manhattan (6th Ave and 36 st)
I always loved the Williamsburg pizza grandma slice
MO’s general
I would check out Pizza Suprema if you’re going to Vitos
Grandma pizza is the best type of pizza, IMO.
L&B is not a grandma slice, people
Underground Pizza in the Financial District’s vodka grandma slice.
Freddie Prinze Paulie Gee’s slice shop
Nino’s in bay ridge
Believe it or not there is this little pizza joint on Middletown Town Road in the Bronx called Franks Pizza. They make an outstanding Grandmas Pie.
I like upside grandma
Russ on Manhattan ave in Greenpoint
Mimi’s ues goated
Louie’s Pizza in Elmhurst
Hit up corner slice and fini
Many of the best have been mentioned but I’ll add some sleepers :
Brother’s pizza in Staten does a pretty good one
DaVinci on 18th Ave in Brooklyn (but the Sicilian is better )
Not technically a grandma but the Freddie Prinze slice at Paulie Gees slice shop I really enjoy because of the sesame seeds on the bottom
NY Pizza Suprema is respectable
A divisive pick but I like Rizzos
And even though not exactly grandma the squares at mamas too I think are quality
Franks pizza Middletown Rd, Bronx, NY
DaNonna Rosa… trust
Bleecker Street. Their most famous slice is the Nonna Maria, which is Grandma toppings on a round pie. But they also do a traditional square Grandma which is just as good.
Vito’s 😍
Fazio’s
F&F in Carroll Gardens has a solid one
Sals on wyckoff ave in bushwick. Never makes a list but that slice is crack!!
Luna Pizza
House of Pizza and Calzone in Cobble Hill!
Village square
Mama’s too
Lo Duca in Newkirk Plaza, Ditmas Park, Brooklyn
Salvos on the UES is excellent.
Gotham Pizza York Ave and 76 is superb.
The folks at r/pizza would have a shit fit if they knew people on here confusing grandma pies with Sicilian pizza…
Pepperoni grandma at “Rome to Brooklyn” near Grand st (L)
https://imgur.com/a/ZCJcEVB
Louie’s in elmhurst