Hi S3 family!
As always, thanks for tuning in 🙂 Always appreciate it!
Our website: www.S3Lifestyle.com
Instagram: www.instagram.com/s3_lifestyle_
Business Inquiries: Laila@S3lifestyle.com
Come say hi on Instagram –
#bestrestaurants #michelinrestaurant #chef #restaurantreview #worlds50best #finedining #foodiecouple #tastingmenu
today we’re in San Francisco California
And we’re eating at one of the
country’s most celebrated 3 Michelin star
restaurants Atelier Crenn! Chef Crenn’s rise reads like
a Hollywood movie she’s the only American woman
to win three Michelin stars in history she’s
been named the best female chef in the world
she has her own Netflix documentary been an iron
chef and even consulted for the acclaimed horror
movie the menu… with these credentials we expected
this meal to be near perfection by the end of the
meal we realized our review is going to be a
little controversial. Walking in Atelier Crenn
the space is smaller than you expect the tables
are closed together and unique design elements
underwhelm in real life. Today we’ll be eating
a 19 course pescatarian dairy-free tasting menu
highlighting regions in Central and Northern
California at a price of $475 usd per person
Let’s get started! First a play on the cocktail
Kir Royale here apple juice instead of champagne
incase in a cocoa butter shell Chef Crenn is from
Brittany so we call kir Britton instead just
got to pop right there on your palette… refreshing
nice cocoa butter on the outside it’s a shot in
the sphere beautiful really fresh and quickly
to follow our first dish two small recreated
cherry bombs or roasted peppers from San Joaquin
Valley when you sit down at a restaurant of
this caliber you expect to be ‘wowed’ the opening
sequence of a 3 michelin restaurant is their
opportunity for great first impressions just
look at Crenn’s colleagues in California this is
Addison and look at what’s waiting for you
when you first sit down and Single
Thread and at Crenn this is the opening sequence
We travel to Point Reyes along the
northern coast to enjoy one of Crenn’s favorite
ingredients the oyster faux oyster shell from
Champagne mignonette that we’ve frozen with liquid
nitrogen, oyster belly from point reyes, lemon gel we
have loveage gel and a champagne mignonette gel
so it sort of tastes like a fully loaded oyster…
that’s a lot of sea that’s too much sea one of
the rare times Laila I disagree, I love that dish
if you were on the beach it was in the winter
cold salinity to it so it’s very creative next a
carrot and pea taco with produce from Chef Crenn’s
own Blue Bell Farm in Sonoma that uses organic and
regenerative practices to produce the freshest
ingredients to supply to the restaurant there’s
a smoked carrot puree in the Middle with some
botargo, english peas tossed into sherry vinegar some
cured egg yoke as well… when you eat vegetables
picked fresh from the chef’s own farm you expect
an explosion of flavors, this was a bit soft un-dimensional
and frankly lacked the flavor we
were expecting now it’s off to Monteray where
they source crab for this next course this is
three unique preparations of dungeness crab this is a
savory ice cream with trout row and fennel flour,
tapioca crisp tomato chili and crap powder with
a crap miso underneath and finally just a very
humble broth… the ice cream almost has a semifreddo
consistencies, cold ice cream hot broth crispy
cracker everything in between bit of pop of roe this
a great dish… it’s back to Blue Bell farm for a
beet course beet ceviche huckberry Jam preserved
plum powder overall this was extremely acidic
and mouth puckering sour not much else going on
to be honest a roasted beet dehydrated fermented
reconstituted in fortified wine and beet juice
again we’re at one of the best restaurants in
the country and they’ve chosen to highlight a
single bee the Beet is poorly peeled with gouges
and they’ve chosen to use one garnish but it was
wilted the third dish interestingly not a beet
a tempura fried perilla leaf or shisho, mole made
from black and pepper and spices a tomato dish
showcasing the different flavors and varietal of
tomato and basil roasted pickled stuffed with
trout and marinated the recreated Vine from
basil puree top with nasturtium flowers and fresh basil
trout broth puff quinoa and salty trout flakes
so as soon as you eat it you get a very
heavy smoke trout flavor it disappears
immediately and then it’s just tomato acid
and crunchy basil very creative very fun
trout with plankton I mean at face value there’s
not much going on here the trout is fresh it’s
a bit bland for me… the abalone brings her memories
of being back at home in Brittney France mustard
seed, tarragon, abalone livers and then abalone XO
underneath everything a little bit of sauerkraut
made with cabbage from our farm… the next sequence
was build your own boa, dry age black cod glazed
in a caramel sauce grilled over binchotan this was
served with a fresh steamed boa bun kimchi marigold
flowers preserved plums and sesame vinaigrette
herb salad this looked like it was going to be a
lot of fun unfortunately this is what happened ….
we’re going to… it’s okay…. just for the record I
don’t know what I’m doing with the rest of that
fish…. it’s not ‘smoosh-able’ oh no….. this is a mess
flavor profile the boa was dry and overall
the dish was very salty the single tiny boa
you can see was not nearly enough to hold all
the ingredients on the table now you’re going
to say just ask for more boa… reasonable but this
is a three star Michelin restaurant they should
have thought of that for you … maybe this is a
good time to talk about service here you can
see Adrian asking the server to remove the
prior course because he almost walked away
leaving dirty dishes on the table…. okay if you
can believe it that’s the end of the mains just
to recap the only substantial amount of protein
we had this whole meal was a one 4oz piece of
cod okay transitioning to desserts replacing
the traditional cheese course we had a small
leak tart creamy leak mousse charred leak and
buckweat tart and dehydrated leaks on top is
it’s very bland… I can’t distinguish a flavor… I have a
couple of guests coming through the kitchen
this is the courtyard which connects
everything together as you can see a
pretty high traffic area especially this time
of night when we’re getting everything ready
for a whole second seating and moving other
people from the first one over to Bar Crenn
where we’re on the way right now after a
gracious tour of the kitchen we were led
into the adjoining space Bar Crenn to enjoy
a dessert sequence we were not expecting
this space was a wonderful contrast to the main
dining room and a very nice way to end the meal
the vibe was a 1950s Tokyo music bar with
beautiful elements including Moroccan rugs
and Ottomans and a old ceiling the desserts
were created and made by Dominique’s longtime
partner Juan Contreras who worked with her for many
years prior to opening Atelier Crenn together in
2011 five desserts were presented in
sequence first a tequila press Korean
melon a wonderful start exceptionally crunchy
with a fresh lingering tequila aftertaste next
a playful take on Pina Cola where even the
wrapper was edible made from rice paper stone
fruit tart Peruvian mint and peaches, kakigori
traditional Japanese shaved ice topped with
strawberries basil from the farm and a coconut
condensed milk base a strawberry tomato basil
Mochi incredible Chef Juan is on points a
sweet corn marshmallow ice cream flavors
of olive oil and lemon and is salty finish
I am so into these desserts very Whimsical
finally some petit fours to end the wonderful
dessert sequence… based on our ranking system
Atelier Crenn gets an S1 to find out why please
visit our website thanks for watching!
41 Comments
I've been hearing this for years: the most hyped-up restaurant ever, solely because she is a woman. I had a similar disappointment at the three-star Arzak in San Sebastian, Spain. It was a horrible experience, with a total bill of 1200 euros for two people, just for the full menu and wine. This goes to show that a gender quota makes no sense.
Wow! Agree, not much food in that courses.
That's one thing which pescatarian menu's desire, which is to be able to wow the guests. That actually looked like an attempt to get a michelin star rather than a 3 michelin star course.
this is fascinating. you dont get videos like these very often…
Someone getting fired because of that beet
She's French not American. If you can't even get the right then, wow….
I'm disappointed for you 😢
We ate at Atelier Crenn back in 2014 when it was a two-star Michelin restaurant and it was comically awful. Alas, it doesn't seem like much has changed.
Representative of San Francisco itself, perhaps?
Someone has upped their thumbnail game!!
I agree with your assessment. When I went it was underwhelming and was too dessert heavy. I can't recommend Atelier Crenn. Instead go to Single Thread…still probably one of the best dining experience I had.
Its nice to see videos that show that even high end restaurants have its flaws. I have gone to places that is not even michellin stared with way better presentation.
"She was the advisor of the movie "The Menu"." That explains a couple of things about the movie
wow, i can't believe how sparse the offerings were. Looks very unimpressive.
That's too bad. I have been 3 times and I adored the experience each time. The food was outstanding. I got perfection! Cheers!
The guy showing you around the kitchen has a jacket that is 3 sizes too small. That button could kill
I really enjoyed the new(?) format of you guys talking to the camera about the meal after the fact.
Definitely going to be taking this one off my list for now, the other California 3 stars look so much better. Thanks for the review!
Dominique Crenn announced several years ago that she no longer cares about Michelin star reviews anymore. She'd rather cook to make her customers happy. Restaurants like Atelier Crenn are always pushing the envelope, some creations are a hit, others not so much.
Thanks for being candid and sharing your honest opinion! Love your channel!
awwww I thought you two would've had an amazing time at Atelier Crenn. I went back in 2019, a week after they received their third star. The menu I got is DRASTICALLY different than what you two got. Nevertheless, thank you for the insights <3.
She’s so American that she has a French accent. Like, huh? Only American female chef what?!
love your very honest review on a very well known restaurant and I can. see us a chef this food is over rated for the value and the price
I think the comparisons are being picky. Every resource is unique and has a right not to be compared with others.
Thanks for the brutal honesty. Absolutely necessary. I recently left a 3/5 review in a British fine dining location. They mustn’t have liked it as they soon blocked me following their socials. Keep the honesty up, both of you!
Wow jeez… That looked like a very underwhelming meal 😢
Love it, I hate when alleged foodies act like every Michelin restaurant is the be all end all
I had a meal there a few years ago and had a very similar experience. Pretty disappointing meal overall and honestly left feeling hungry.
good honest review, I almost feel that these 3 Michelin stars are just all showy and no substance – I mean sure it will look good on your instagram but ultimately the proof is in the pudding – thank you again for a straight up review, it's refreshing!
great video. gg.
Huh! What???
Before the desserts, that looked like a 400 calories dinner..
I'm sorry for the experience you had, God bless you both
The desserts saved them from getting an S 12
Thanks for posting this. All too often, reviews of these restaurants are far too fawning. I would be very unhappy if I shelled out $450 per person for this.
Did business with Chef Crenn years back. Ate there when she had 2 Stars and the meal blew me away. The 'walk in the forest' dish still resonates. $125 for 5 courses and was very soulful. Different than what I saw in this video. Chef Juan is a truly nice guy and his desserts are phenomenal!
The waiters really did have a great leather daddy porn thing going though 🎉
The desserts looked great at least
She's French not American….????
Beautiful❤
This video shows that this restaurant charging almost $500 usd per person for the menu was pure robbery. To be honest, this is the worst reviewed 3 star restaurant video I have ever seen.
So cool of you to use someone else’s attempt at having a good life to make some views for yourself 👍👉👉