Recipe: https://eatsimplefood.com/easy-buttery-shrimp/

This easy and fast pan seared shrimp is cooked with butter and olive oil to create crispy browned shrimp on the outside and tender moist shrimp inside.

The secret to searing delicate meat like shrimp and fish is in the details. Bring a non-stick skillet to medium high heat, melt butter and olive oil together, place shrimp in the pan close but not too close, and moderate the heat as you see the butter browning and shrimp cooking.

Likewise, you want enough fat (butter and oil) but not too much fat. Too much fat will boil the shrimp. Just enough fat will cook / brown the butter to onto the shrimp and make the outside crispy and seared.

Butter has a low smoking point (300F) so it burns easy, especially compared to other fats. Olive oil has a higher (but still mediumish 375F) smoking point and raises the temperature that you can sear with while also imparting the smoother fruitier flavor of olive oil.

Either way, you don’t really want the pan to smoke too much. If something is burning, remove the pan from the stovetop immediately. Try adding a little olive oil to the pan when it’s removed to calm the whole pan down.

Shrimp only need to cook for ~ 1 ½ – 2 minutes on one side and another minute on the other side. The trick is to get the beautiful sear on the first side at that takes a little longer cooking time.

Don’t mess with the shrimp while they’re cooking on the first side. DON’T MESS WITH THEM! They need time to create the fond (browned bits) on the shrimp and in the pan. If you are gonna peek, start by looking at one shrimp gently (see video). Be patient. Be zen.

Don’t crowd the pan. Use a pan that’s appropriate for the amount of shrimp. 1 pound of peeled and deveined shrimp will fit nicely into ~ 10″ – 12″ skillet.

If the pan is too crowded, the shrimp will steam. If the pan is not crowded and has too much space, all the butter and oil will burn and be gross instead of getting a sweet browned caramelization. Too much space can ruin the fat (butter or oil) that the shrimp is cooked in. Burnt fat is gross.

Use a non-stick skillet. It’s just easier for seafood and meats with not a lot of fat. It’s easier to learn, easier to cook, and easier to clean for most of us. Non-stick pans are more forgiving.

Stainless steel pans and cast iron pans are also options but non-stick is where it’s at if you don’t normally get the sear that you’re looking for.

This is a basic simple recipe for an easy and fast dinner. Add some garlic or herbs or spices as desired.

Serve buttery shrimp over a salad, as an appetizer, over pasta, or over your favorite grain or vegetable.

Dairy Free folks can use a dairy alternative. Whole30 and Paleo folks can use clarified butter.

Don’t like peeling and deveining shrimp? Buy them already done. Most grocery stores will also sell cooked shrimp which would work for this recipe.

Whole foods will peel and devein shrimp at no additional cost most of the time if you call ahead. Shrimp can also be peeled and deveined after boiling if you don’t like to peel and devein raw.

Raw frozen shrimp that have been defrosted will also work for this cold shrimp salad recipe.

Keep the raw shrimp on ice while you peel and devein it. This step is not necessary if working with a small amount of shrimp or if you’re fast with your “peel and devein shrimp game”.

Ingredients:

• 1 pound shrimp, peeled and deveined
• 1 tablespoon olive oil
• 1 ½ tablespoon butter
• salt to taste
• black pepper to taste
• lemon squeezer, optional for garnish

Directions:

• Pat dry the shrimp (this will help with the sear).

• Lightly salt and pepper shrimp.

• Bring a medium sized pan to medium high heat.

•Add butter and melt. Add olive oil.

• Place shrimp in a single layer into the pan and cook for 1 ½ – 2 minutes or until one side is seared. Don’t disturb the shrimp before seeing a sear on the bottom side.

• Flip shrimp and cook for 30 seconds – 1 minute or until shrimp is cooked through. The second side will sear faster than the first and doesn’t need as much time unless the shrimp are biggens.

• Salt and pepper to taste and a squeeze of fresh lemon if desired. Happy eating! Beckie

This is buttery pan seared shrimp. It’s easy. It’s fast. It’s crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. So I have about a one pound / one and a third pound of peeled and deveined shrimp here. And I’ve dried them off. I dry them off, because I’m trying to get that sear. So you don’t want any moisture on the shrimp. I’m spreading them out on a plate and lightly salt and peppering them. I’m going to take it over to the stovetop. i’m going to use a 12 inch non-stick skillet. So non-stick skillets are easy to clean, easy to use, and they’re very forgiving. And they’re good with really delicate meats, especially shrimp and fish. So I’ve got butter and also olive oil. Whole30 and paleo – you can use clarified butter. But this is just butter and olive oil. And I’m going to melt that. And this is at a medium-high heat, but I’m going to moderate that and bring it down probably to a medium heat as the pan starts to smoke. Butter has a low smoking point, which means it burns easy. That’s why you want the olive oil in there – to help kind of temper it. Smoke is okay, but you don’t want a ton of smoke. Like – remove it from heat if stuff is burning. You don’t want burnt shrimp. You want crispy shrimp that’s brown, that’s got that fond – those caramelized bits. So, this is a 12 inch skillet that fits about one and a third pounds. Use a smaller skillet if you have less shrimp. You don’t want them too crowded. You don’t want too much space, because then the butter will burn and burnt butter is kind of gross. So after about one and a half to two minutes check a couple of the shrimp. In the meantime, don’t disturb them – like wait until they’re brown. You can’t see this here, but they’re brown. You’ll see it later. So when you flip them to the second side, you can add a little bit of garlic there. This is only going to cook for another 30 seconds to a minute, just until the shrimps are completely cooked through. And you can see that they’re beautiful, nice, and brown. You’ll see it in the pictures online as well. So now’s the time to hit it with some lemon juice if you like – that’s optional. You could have always seasoned the shrimp with anything you like – if you like old bay or if you like rosemary, thyme – knock that out at the beginning. And there you have it – there’s a pan-seared buttery shrimp. Absolutely amazing. Serve it over salad. Serve it with grains. Eat it as a snack. So delicious. If you’re looking for how to peel and devein shrimp then check out my buttery shrimp with Worcestershire sauce recipe or pickled shrimp. Find this recipe at https://eatsimplefood.com/easy-buttery-shrimp/

23 Comments

  1. To anyone who is reading this, please use chopsticks and not metal tongs. You will ruin your pan.
    If you can't use chop sticks, than use a cast Iron Skillet. You will get a better sear anyways.

    -Source: I was raised right.

  2. I would think that if you’re using butter (low smoking point), you’d want to use avo oil with it, not another oil with a low smoking point. Shrimp still looks tasty, though! Making shrimp tacos with mine, thanks!

  3. Tried and smelled so good! Anyone else queezy about touching fresh shrimp? I shivered my way though breaking their heads off and reaching in for the vein. I'm a grown man.little embarrassing lol.

  4. YOU ARE A LIFE SAVER!! I made this for dinner and even my picky child enjoyed it. I’m learning how to cook and this is definitely going to be one of my go to

  5. Thank you. I kept just trying to figure it out by trial and error. It would only come out right like 10% of the time. It seems my big mistake was adding water. LOL! Silly me.
    So really, Thank you.

Write A Comment