Claire Saffitz Answers Subscribers’ Baking Questions | Ask Me Anything | Claire-ified
In this engaging YouTube session, culinary expert Claire Saffitz takes on the challenge of answering her subscribers’ most pressing baking questions. Join her as she shares valuable insights, expert tips, and practical advice, turning the video into an interactive and informative baking Q&A experience. Whether you’re a seasoned baker or just starting out, Claire’s expertise promises to unravel the mysteries behind your top baking queries, making this session a must-watch for anyone looking to enhance their baking skills.
#clairesaffitz #baking #interview
00:00 Intro
00:29 Regret / revise / republish
01:24 How To Bake From Frozen
02:25 Who keeps the leftovers?
03:03 Claire Saffitz Homemade Jam
03:44 Where To Start Baking
04:48 Recipe development defeat
05:49 A half-sized cake
07:13 Favorite recipes
07:56 Too scared to bake
08:33 Sliding Danishes
09:57 Cat cam
What’s for Dessert by Claire Saffitz is out now: https://geni.us/WjcIbfp
Dessert Person Online: https://www.dessertperson.com/
Claire on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/csaffitz/?h…
Claire Merchandise: https://www.dessertperson.com/buystuff
Penguin Random House Books: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/
Video Series:
Producer/Director: Vincent Cross
Camera Operator: Calvin Robertson
Editor/Motion Graphics: Hal McFall
Animation Credits:
Character Designer/Animator/Backgrounds: Jack Sherry
Character Rigger: Johara Dutton
hi everyone I’m Claire saffitz welcome to my home kitchen today I don’t have a recipe for you we’re mixing it up a little bit I am going to be answering questions that were left on the community board on YouTube always love answering reader questions because troubleshooting is like a big part of what I do you know I’d like to ask a question something’s bugging me been on my mind be great if you clarify is is there a recipe that you look back on with regret how often do you revise SL republish recipes I mean I don’t really look on recipes with regret that sound that’s like too strong there are things that I would change about a lot of recipes sometimes I look back on recipes from the early part of my career and just feel like they’re too fussy like I would just like tone it down I think in the early part of my career it’s like oh I’m excited to like show off technique and knowledge and you know incorporate that into recipes and it’s just like not that important and doesn’t necessarily make it better so generally I would go back and make it a little simpler but no like specific regret because it all compounds and like makes you better so I couldn’t really have it be any other way um and I don’t really republish recipes unless there would be like a tremendous error but that’s never really happened I mean there’s errors definitely from you know cookbooks but they’re minor okay if you freeze cookie dough is it best to bake from Frozen but for longer than the listed time or let it thaw and come up to room temperature then bake as per recipe it’s up to you I think for ease just take it right out of the freezer put it on the baking sheet and bake it add another minute or two to the bake time there’s really no added benefit to thawing at first just keep it simple bake it straight from Frozen great question hi Claire I love your video so much thank you do you have any tips for transitioning into working in a professional Bakery with only home baking experience I would say just remain very open to instruction and to correction because in any kind of professional kitchen setting like there’s going to be a particular way that that place likes to do things and to sort of be trainable and be open be very oriented towards learning like be a sponge in the beginning and just go into it with the attitude that’s like I’m here to learn try to be less focused on like showing what you already know from your home baking experience and more just learn the ropes hi Claire I have a Baker’s etiquette question if you bring a whole cake or pie to someone’s home as a dinner guest who keeps any leftovers I feel like it’s nice to leave them with the host but I absolutely love some leftover pie for breakfast all right this one to me is clear you bring something to someone’s house that is for them that’s theirs that is the hosts that is your duty as the guest like you’re bringing something that belongs to them if it’s like a super super close friend maybe you could be like hey could I just like take a little piece of pie home in a in like a container to enjoy tomorrow but like if you like breakfast pie then like make a second pie sorry would you ever do videos on things like jam making SL canning I’m super interested in learning to preserve my own food preserving to me is like the next Frontier in my own learning because now we’re like growing food this is really more of like a thing in the summer for us because we like we have fruit trees and a garden and fruit bushes and so I love making Jam I have tried traditional canning in the past with a caner and the boiling water and everything there’s a lot to learn part of me is like do I want to really weighed into that mess because of all of the food safety rules around it and so there’s a lot of Education that I think I need to do but I love the idea and so I’m kind of slowly learning on my own and hopefully at some point we’ll have info to share but love Jam Love preserving in your opinion what is the best way for someone to start baking and what do you think is important for them to know I’m an novice baker having only baked things from a package for instance a cake mix but I want to try and make many of your recipes I just don’t know where to start I mean I wouldn’t start with something that you know is going to be extremely complicated I would maybe avoid like a yeasted recipe because that’s a variable that you have to control that is like not something you need to do as a beginner other than that I would just say start with the thing you want to eat pick a well you know a tested well-written recipe I would say one of my own um because that’s what I strive for and then make it a few times make it five times make it over and over again because that’s where you really do the learning that’s where you start to learn like what variable is different why does the cookie spread more you know in this oven versus that oven you know the temperature of your butter all these things so the way that you learn there’s no to me there’s no shortcut it’s about practice and doing it and often you get the benefit more when you’re doing the same thing over and over again versus picking a new recipe every time so number one piece of advice but love the question has there ever been a time during recipe development where you completely gave up and accepted defeat if so what was the food item and the problems you faced with it yes I have given up in recipe development but I wouldn’t say that it feels like accepting defeat it’s more of like you’re being humbled a little bit and it’s more about understanding that sometimes like if you you can’t put a square peg in a round hole sort of so sometimes when I’ve given up on a recipe it’s because I kind of realize like this doesn’t want to be a recipe it’s like my I had an idea there’s a conception and the execution it just doesn’t match the expectation and like I’m not going to be able to bridge that Gap so it’s like I I need to Pivot like my idea needs to change my expectation needs to change so that’s really kind of what happens like an example is like I tried to do a recipe for grapes jubile like a grapes flambe and it doesn’t work because grapes don’t behave the same way as like cherries when they’re cooked so it’s like it just it just didn’t want to be the recipe that I wanted it to be so to move on hey Claire if I’m baking a cake and want to cut the ingredients by half how do I calculate cooking time for a now half-sized cake if it’s smaller it should bake faster right really really good question and not the simple answer you might expect like you would think half the amount half the bake time it’s not always the case it depends a lot on the dimensions of the thing you’re baking so maybe you have like a layer cake recipe and you cut the recipe in half and you but you bake it in a loaf pan it’s not going to be half the time a lot of it depends on the volume of batter and the amount of like I want to say the words thermal Mass that’s not right but it’s like the amount of mass of batter that the heat from the oven needs to penetrate to get to the center to make sure it’s fully cooked that is the main determinant so if you you could be baking like a huge quantity of batter but in a super thin layer and it’s going to bake a lot faster than something even that’s half the size but that’s like in a much sort of taller vessel so it really depends probably not the simple answer you wanted but watch it I would say start with half the baked time but like be alert your nose like be on alert be looking at it have the oven light on and then as you gain experience you’ll know like oh if I’m only if I was going to bake two cake layers but I’m only baking one maybe it takes 2third of the time it’s that kind of thing it’s just like it’s physics what is your favorite Julia child/ barefit contesta SL other famous female Baker slf’s recipe oh my gosh great question I mean I have so many like favorite or like beloved figures like an AA or A Julie child I don’t cook a lot of the recipes cuz like so much of my life is developing my own thing and also just kind of more intuitive type of cooking or baking but Julie child has this really famous chocolate almond cake that I’ve made several times there’s a Barefoot Contessa like coconut cupcake recipe that I’ve made like this is going back like a long time but that’s like so delicious so there’s a lot but they’re super quirky because it’s like I’m not always trying a lot of their like recipes in their Library any tips for people who are too scared to make anything because if it comes out bad it’s a waste of food love your content Claire and crew thank you I will say that having chickens and composting does help to spin your idea of like food waste more positively but of course I understand the fear of sunken costs like time and money and ingredients like going to waste because something didn’t turn out try to like keep it simple keep manage your expectations start with one of those recipes on the internet that has like 10,000 F star reviews it would be relatively uncommon for something to be to turn out so badly using like a well tested recipe that you couldn’t even eat it so I hear you but I would just say like push through the fear hi Claire when I make your blueberry cream cheese danishes the layers often slide off of each other like a deck of cards in the oven what do I do to get them to stop sliding off yes I know what you’re referring to usually this is a problem when the butter is too warm the proofing is at room temperature because if it’s not at room temp and it’s too cold the yeast won’t actually do anything and you don’t get the proofing and puffing that you need one thing you can try is after you proof them put them back in the fridge or even the freezer if you have the space for like 10 minutes five if it’s in the freezer 10 in the fridge and that is going to help sort of set the butter and you will probably find that this doesn’t happen as much there that separation is normal some kind of like sliding around is normal but yeah it sounds like a butter temp issue oh that’s it okay actually it’s like an amazing group of questions love this round I love the mix of kind of like more theoretical questions and then like very practical troubleshooting for people’s baking woes Vinnie is working okay vny is working on a way to feature your baking video questions in the next episode I see so we can take a look at some of your baking fails although I mean it’s okay fails it’s fine sometimes they fails okay so share some of your questions in the comments below and thank you so much for watching and don’t forget to like And subscribe n [Music]
37 Comments
Any idea what to do when a graham cracker crust is too dry and crumbly? I've tried so many times to get a good graham cracker crust (using the no-bake grapefruit bar recipe), but every time it comes out just disintegrating off the final dish.
Claire! – This was phenomenal! Thanks for sharing your insight! 🎉💚✨
I baked your amazing brown butter cookies (which brown butter is now my deity in baking btw) I have a fan oven and followed your cook temps and timings but they were really over done. What did I do wrong?
Question: Have you ever tried making any of the "no-knead" bread recipes that are all over the internet? The ones where you "stretch and fold" the dough 4 times at 30 minute intervals, then bake it. Jim Lahey has a recipe for it. During an interview with Mark Bittman, he suggested putting a little vinegar in the dough. Suggestion: Please start a segment where someone bakes (via zoom) what you are baking while you give them instructions and tips. You did it once with your brother-in-law and it was hilarious. Thanks so much (you and the crew), love your work, love your show.
i literally rewatched the first one of these the other day. i was wishing i could ask some questions but i didn’t think you’d do it again. please feel free to do these again, they’re very helpful and entertaining!
my question is: is it stealing to use someone else’s recipe for profit? not like publishing their recipe on your website without credit or anything, i mean if you sell the product of the recipe through a restaurant, bakery, etc. is that stealing?
I've always struggled with deciding if I should bake with convection or conventional setting, eg: should I bake cookies in conventional but breads in convection? and if someone only owns one of the 2, how might the setting affect the results of baked goods (if any). Thanks Claire and crew!
I want to know what you like to make a lot for yourself? What are your go-tos?
Thank you for teaching the younger generations basic manners. Things are so much more casual than even 10 or 20 years ago, but many younger people do the most awkward things that make me cringe, Two things in particular. There is a correct way to enter and exit a car. Regardless of gender please sit gracefully then bring your legs in. Never knee first on the seat. Also I often see young ladies who have gone to great effort and expense with their appearance pulling and adjusting their garment usually with an unpleasant facial expression indicating discomfort. Please go to the ladies room to adjust yourself, and keep a pleasant or at least neutral facial expression when out and about.
Thanks for the video
How are subscribers notified via "community board" when Claire is taking questions? I always miss it!
I would love to know how to start developing my own recipes, I can improvise with cooking well enough but when it comes to baking I'm not sure how to make/test changes with purpose. I struggle to understand the purpose of each individual ingredient in a recipe and how to adjust them, but your recipes have so much more insight than most I can find online. Do you have any tips for an aspiring recipe developer?
hi Claire your oat and pecan brittle cookies are my favorite cookies to make ive made them at least 10 times however recently ive been told I have to cut out gluten and dairy from my diet as it has started to make me sick and I was wondering if you have any tips for converting this recipe to make it gluten and dairy free.
ooo, whats in the keg tap behind you?
I think you're beautiful.
As someone who just started baking 4 years ago (largely because of Claire) I can say it's ok to make mistakes early on, and don't be afraid! Even now, the first time I try a recipe I make a mistake. Every time! Maybe it looks like a mess, or the texture is off. But usually the flavor is still great and people enjoy it anyway, but I can go back and figure out what I did wrong and make it much better the next time. It's a matter of getting the temp/time right, or figuring out which ingredients or equipment are essential and can't be swapped out.
The improvement is so satisfying and rewarding and totally worth the early mistakes!
This was fun, wish it was 20 mins longer lol do more Q&A
I love your videos and have been a fan from the very beginning. I'm in desperate need for advice regarding pastry making in warm/humid temps. It takes me hours to make/roll/top/crimp even a simple pie in the beautiful Austin Texas because I'm constantly having to put it back in the freezer after handling it for only a couple minutes! I also fine kerrygold melts faster? Or is that my imagination.
Question: I would love to develop my own baking recipes but the chemistry is beyond me, especially when it comes to raising agents. For example, when developing a standard sized cake what makes you call for baking powder versus baking soda( or both)? And then how do you decide the proportions? I.e. one teaspoon or one tablespoon? Is it all just trial and error?
i want like 3 hours of this
Hi Claire! I'd love for you to do a series where you "Host" a dinner. Where you'd make appetizers mains and dessert. I feel like being an young adult is trying to get to host a dinner and would love to have some good recipes lol
Is there a way to add a yeast-testing step to recipes that do not already include it? I have had my yeast be dead (but not expired) SOOO many times, and it is so frustrating! Because of this, I currently limit myself to recipes that have the yeast-testing step already included, but can I do it with any recipe? It would require adding water/surar/milk/etc or changing the order things are added in, so I have not tried it
If a crème brûlée didn’t set in the fridge overnight, is there a way to salvage or repurpose it?
that pie question is hilarious.
Hey Claire! I was wondering is there a difference in baking certain pastries within the realm of using a gas oven as opposed to an electric oven?
Claire how can I improve my cat making biscuits. Skills are lacking
Love your recipes. They always turn out great with the exception of your white cake as per the confetti cake recipe. For some reason the cake always sinks a little when cooling with a dense centre as a result. Do you know what could be going wrong?
Idk if this is dumb but I’ve messed up more than once thinking I can use soften butter as regular butter thinking I was the issue
I just want to know what the tap in the background is…coldbrew? Beer? Seltzer??? 😂
As someone who is a decent but in no way expert baker, if you've made stuff from a box, you're already a lot of the way to making stuff from scratch! The only difference is measuring out the dry ingredients yourself, and anyone can do that as long as you have measuring cups and spoons!
Is that cold brew on tap behind you?!
I love these videos! Thanks guys!
She should really dye hair she looks 50
Is that draft for coffee or beer? I NEED to know!
Any recommendations on how to swap nuts in recipes with seeds or other ingredients for those with tree nut and peanut allergies ? I keep running into this issue where there don’t seem to be super easy swaps.
Hey @CSaffitz, I just want to know if you’re pro-Israel or pro-Palestine. Because I read on Wikipedia that you’re a Jewish Woman.
So I’m pro-white feminist/zionist and proud! ✊🏻
is that a beer spout/faucet behind Claire?