I liked this dessert when I got it — the cheesecakey part is great. I wish the Jello were a little more tender (maybe preparing it “harder” makes the dessert more consistent).
WindjammerX
I love that they call this a salad.
Party-Veterinarian60
Love this post. Intriguing, unique dessert I’d never heard of. Thanks for sharing fajita tits.
outlawlooseandrunnin
It’s very possible I went on a bad day, but when I ordered this it was so bad nobody in my group of 4 wanted another bite. The jello was so rubbery that by the time you finished chewing it all of the other layers had separated and already gone down. It was very unpleasant
Hardp0rec0rn
Loved this dessert everything else we had was as good as it needed to be. As someone who had been to the old Kellogg’s this is an enormous improvement and hope they have a lot of success being open 24 hours.
Broad_Strokes_paint
My mom always makes this for the holidays. One of those strange mid-century recipes that shouldn’t slap but does.
halfadash6
I made a raspberry version of this over the summer and it was 👌. Classic retro dessert!
DawsonMaestro414
I tried this last week because I had heard hype about it. It’s very mid. Not sure what the hype is. It tastes exactly how it looks.
Lyna_hot
looks great
Vindadu13
I had heard that Kelloggs was closing down. Haven’t been that way in a while. Anyone know what’s going on over there?
childpeas
i had this dessert and it was very odd. something about the proportions of the elements was off. some bites were good, some bites were awful. this was in the first couple weeks it opened so i’m assuming they’ve improved since then.
Grouchy-Oven877
I had three of their dessert this past November. I was completely underwhelmed.
Other-Confidence9685
…
lodidodi64
My mom made this for us as a kid my wife thinks it’s trashy haha.
thethirstbk
I had this dessert and ate the whole thing but still couldn’t figure out if I actually liked it
jazzindigomango
Oh wow. I have never encountered this incredible substance outside of the deep south. A typical thanksgiving where I grew up featured this as a side NOT a dessert. Can’t wait to go try this, thanks!
broadly89
i am from the south where this dish originated, and i will die on this hill: IT IS NOT A DESSERT!!!!!! it is meant to be eaten as a side dish!! a very very sweet side dish!!!!
Professional_Top440
I grew up eating this. The ratio is off and there doesn’t seem to be frozen strawberries in the jello.
If I saw this at someone’s house, I’d think they weren’t a good cook
Aaero79
I grew up eating this stuff. It sounds strange but tbh it’s always fire. Pro tip: bring it to a cookout, everyone will love you
Lethave
Love that they found a way to stick around but Kellogg’s was such a time and a place, I don’t think I’ve ever been there not drunk and or hungover and fighting to rejoin the living 😂
Nermal_Nobody
I liked this dish but the pretzel crust on this one and the other pies the day I went were soooooo super salty something was off. Overall I felt their food was very mid and I was excited to try the new rollout. Btw- I love salty sweet but this was excessive.
BankshotMcG
Kellogg was always beloved but since its comeback the desserts have been eye-boggling.
26 Comments
https://www.kelloggsdinernyc.com/
How is it?
What did you think?
I liked this dessert when I got it — the cheesecakey part is great. I wish the Jello were a little more tender (maybe preparing it “harder” makes the dessert more consistent).
I love that they call this a salad.
Love this post. Intriguing, unique dessert I’d never heard of. Thanks for sharing fajita tits.
It’s very possible I went on a bad day, but when I ordered this it was so bad nobody in my group of 4 wanted another bite. The jello was so rubbery that by the time you finished chewing it all of the other layers had separated and already gone down. It was very unpleasant
Loved this dessert everything else we had was as good as it needed to be. As someone who had been to the old Kellogg’s this is an enormous improvement and hope they have a lot of success being open 24 hours.
My mom always makes this for the holidays. One of those strange mid-century recipes that shouldn’t slap but does.
I made a raspberry version of this over the summer and it was 👌. Classic retro dessert!
I tried this last week because I had heard hype about it. It’s very mid. Not sure what the hype is. It tastes exactly how it looks.
looks great
I had heard that Kelloggs was closing down. Haven’t been that way in a while. Anyone know what’s going on over there?
i had this dessert and it was very odd. something about the proportions of the elements was off. some bites were good, some bites were awful. this was in the first couple weeks it opened so i’m assuming they’ve improved since then.
I had three of their dessert this past November. I was completely underwhelmed.
…
My mom made this for us as a kid my wife thinks it’s trashy haha.
I had this dessert and ate the whole thing but still couldn’t figure out if I actually liked it
Oh wow. I have never encountered this incredible substance outside of the deep south. A typical thanksgiving where I grew up featured this as a side NOT a dessert. Can’t wait to go try this, thanks!
i am from the south where this dish originated, and i will die on this hill: IT IS NOT A DESSERT!!!!!! it is meant to be eaten as a side dish!! a very very sweet side dish!!!!
I grew up eating this. The ratio is off and there doesn’t seem to be frozen strawberries in the jello.
If I saw this at someone’s house, I’d think they weren’t a good cook
I grew up eating this stuff. It sounds strange but tbh it’s always fire. Pro tip: bring it to a cookout, everyone will love you
Love that they found a way to stick around but Kellogg’s was such a time and a place, I don’t think I’ve ever been there not drunk and or hungover and fighting to rejoin the living 😂
I liked this dish but the pretzel crust on this one and the other pies the day I went were soooooo super salty something was off. Overall I felt their food was very mid and I was excited to try the new rollout. Btw- I love salty sweet but this was excessive.
Kellogg was always beloved but since its comeback the desserts have been eye-boggling.
I wanna try a bite of this