Who ever lied and said this tastes delicious, you owe me 4 bucks 😤
Tastes like nothing but sugar and chalk with the minuscule amount of strawberry fighting to come through 😠I should’ve just stuck to ol’ faithful B&J
by PetalsOnMars
16 Comments
Dragonfly-Adventurer
Wow. Oddly polarizing. I do think it could use more strawberry but the icing and pastry mix-ins were good for me – but poptarts are about 30% sugarchalk right?
WolfPrincess_
I have half a pint of this sitting in my freezer because I can’t bring myself to finish it. I like the flavor of the ice cream but I don’t really like the big chunky sprinkles and I downright hate the pastry chunks. I wanted to love this flavor ðŸ˜
angrykeyboarder
I can tell by looking at the carton that it’s not delicious.
ih8three6zero
The B&J version is awesome!! Been looking for this one but guess I can stop lol will just buy vanilla and strawberry pop tarts.
ITLevel01
You just described Pop Tarts 😂
stockorbust
Looks artificial ..way to mess up ice-cream .
jeffwingersweiner
They are really pushing this one! I see it everywhere I go. Good to know it’s a hard pass
No-Restaurant-8963
ya i wasnt thrilled either but i still ate the whole thing at once
cancat918
Now I’m worried. I’ve been searching for the Ben & Jerry’s version, though. But I figured I’d try this one if I could find it.
kevnmartin
It’s right there in the name.
Hallelujah289
Huh, which Ben and Jerry’s is that? Is it the topped strawberry tart? Is that one discontinued?
I think I remember having that one and I think it’s probably one of my least favorite Ben and Jerry’s flavors, though I wish I could try it again to make sure. I just did not like the white chocolate ganache top.
I really do like Haagen Dazs Summer Berry Cake Pop though. It does taste like a strawberry cake Pop. Which is not the same as strawberry pop tart but honestly I’m wondering if that flavor in ice cream is not for me. Though I like strawberry pop tarts themselves.
Nearby_Capital1423
Bet that ice cream got nothing but chemicals in it lmaoo
rickjamesia
I am honestly glad someone said it. I was really excited about it, but regretted buying the second pint. I didn’t have the heart to rain on peoples’ parades. I don’t think it’s inedible, I just wouldn’t buy it again.
Important_Produce812
The last blue bell flavor I had disappointed me so bad I don’t even wanna try this one
personwriter
Red #4.
WildVegas
I would recommend Tillamook’s Strawberry. Very nice natural strawberry bits with a tang. It surprised me how good it was.
16 Comments
Wow. Oddly polarizing. I do think it could use more strawberry but the icing and pastry mix-ins were good for me – but poptarts are about 30% sugarchalk right?
I have half a pint of this sitting in my freezer because I can’t bring myself to finish it. I like the flavor of the ice cream but I don’t really like the big chunky sprinkles and I downright hate the pastry chunks. I wanted to love this flavor ðŸ˜
I can tell by looking at the carton that it’s not delicious.
The B&J version is awesome!! Been looking for this one but guess I can stop lol will just buy vanilla and strawberry pop tarts.
You just described Pop Tarts 😂
Looks artificial ..way to mess up ice-cream .
They are really pushing this one! I see it everywhere I go. Good to know it’s a hard pass
ya i wasnt thrilled either but i still ate the whole thing at once
Now I’m worried. I’ve been searching for the Ben & Jerry’s version, though. But I figured I’d try this one if I could find it.
It’s right there in the name.
Huh, which Ben and Jerry’s is that? Is it the topped strawberry tart? Is that one discontinued?
I think I remember having that one and I think it’s probably one of my least favorite Ben and Jerry’s flavors, though I wish I could try it again to make sure. I just did not like the white chocolate ganache top.
I really do like Haagen Dazs Summer Berry Cake Pop though. It does taste like a strawberry cake Pop. Which is not the same as strawberry pop tart but honestly I’m wondering if that flavor in ice cream is not for me. Though I like strawberry pop tarts themselves.
Bet that ice cream got nothing but chemicals in it lmaoo
I am honestly glad someone said it. I was really excited about it, but regretted buying the second pint. I didn’t have the heart to rain on peoples’ parades. I don’t think it’s inedible, I just wouldn’t buy it again.
The last blue bell flavor I had disappointed me so bad I don’t even wanna try this one
Red #4.
I would recommend Tillamook’s Strawberry. Very nice natural strawberry bits with a tang. It surprised me how good it was.