Pastrami followed closely by Cubano but they are all winners.
findnickflannel
all of these sandwiches are amazing but most of these photos are trash representations
Hollandais42
out of these its chicago
kfmw77
This is missing a lot of great American sandwiches and some of the placements are weird but I gotta go with the Philly cheesesteak here, close runner up is fried chicken, then followed up by everything else tied at a close third except the fancy pbj which is in 29th place
usarasa
The New Jersey Sloppy Joe.
But if I must select from the list above, the po boy. Specifically, the 10-napkin roast beef debris po boy at Acme Oyster House.
donttrustmeokay
Top 4: philly, chick sandwich, pastrami, and BBQ. Depends on my mood but damnnn they all sound good right now
footballwr82
Lobster rolls generally come in two options: Connecticut (hot w/ butter) or Maine (cold w/ mayo) style. Neither of those places are Boston.
easycheesay
Roast Pork in Philly over cheesesteak.
KyleSherzenberg
Boston, Miami, NY
Can’t pick one right now… If a Reuben was in there, it would be that
p0st_master
We can agree that’s a trash representation of la. Where’s the torta ?
TheFieldAgent
Philly cheesesteak. The king.
spaceace321
Italian beef is my favorite but can’t say it’s the best
irate_alien
My favorite is the Cuban. I like all the contrasting flavors
isationalist
They did la dirty, I mean they must have like a torta or something better?
TheAndorran
Fuck off with Boston’s being the lobster roll. I’m a Maine islander and we fully claim those and the right to grossly overcharge tourists for them. It’s possible they were invented in Connecticut but we perfected them and are best known for them. That KC sandwich looks incredible, though.
understanding_what
Why is the LA sammie a fancy PB&J and not a torta?
sandwichcandy
How is a pb&j both the best LA has to offer and anywhere near top 9 for America?
Irving_Forbush
Pastrami on rye, followed by the KC BBQ, followed by the cheesesteak.
fuckyouabunch
Fuck Miami. Tampa Cuban.
ReverendHambone
The worst Cuban I’ve ever had is better than any other sandwich I’ve ever had.
teddy_vedder
Where is my beloved chopped cheese 🙁
clallseven
As much as I wanna say Italian beef, it’s cubano for me.
Room_Temp_Coffee
This is anti California slander 🤬
Ok-Commercial-924
Who put a pb&j on this list. It is the only one that is a hard pass with so many others that are great.
Imaginary_Audience_5
Assuming they were all offered at the same price, I’m going lobster roll.
ratmoon25
Ruban
rarehugs
LA has the best Mexican food in Mexico, tf did pbj come from?
SABendiksen
This is impossible
creativespark61
What’s a fancy PB&J?
deadbabysteven
Being from Philly I’ll go with the Cheesesteak closely followed by the Chicago Beef.
Unfortunately the beat sandwich in Philly is not listed which is the Roast Pork. I like John’s the best
Superb-Control5184
Leaving out Pierre’s French Dip from Los Angeles is a damn shame
kinkerbelll
Yeah
Main-Elevator-6908
Philadelphian here voting for the cubano.
MaxxFisher
Italian Beef
ham_solo
Cubano. So many flavors and textures.
CallMeParagon
Missing too many sandwiches to not be rage bait. Reuben #1!
40 Comments
9 way tie
Pastrami followed closely by Cubano but they are all winners.
all of these sandwiches are amazing but most of these photos are trash representations
out of these its chicago
This is missing a lot of great American sandwiches and some of the placements are weird but I gotta go with the Philly cheesesteak here, close runner up is fried chicken, then followed up by everything else tied at a close third except the fancy pbj which is in 29th place
The New Jersey Sloppy Joe.
But if I must select from the list above, the po boy. Specifically, the 10-napkin roast beef debris po boy at Acme Oyster House.
Top 4: philly, chick sandwich, pastrami, and BBQ. Depends on my mood but damnnn they all sound good right now
Lobster rolls generally come in two options: Connecticut (hot w/ butter) or Maine (cold w/ mayo) style. Neither of those places are Boston.
Roast Pork in Philly over cheesesteak.
Boston, Miami, NY
Can’t pick one right now… If a Reuben was in there, it would be that
We can agree that’s a trash representation of la. Where’s the torta ?
Philly cheesesteak. The king.
Italian beef is my favorite but can’t say it’s the best
My favorite is the Cuban. I like all the contrasting flavors
They did la dirty, I mean they must have like a torta or something better?
Fuck off with Boston’s being the lobster roll. I’m a Maine islander and we fully claim those and the right to grossly overcharge tourists for them. It’s possible they were invented in Connecticut but we perfected them and are best known for them. That KC sandwich looks incredible, though.
Why is the LA sammie a fancy PB&J and not a torta?
How is a pb&j both the best LA has to offer and anywhere near top 9 for America?
Pastrami on rye, followed by the KC BBQ, followed by the cheesesteak.
Fuck Miami. Tampa Cuban.
The worst Cuban I’ve ever had is better than any other sandwich I’ve ever had.
Where is my beloved chopped cheese 🙁
As much as I wanna say Italian beef, it’s cubano for me.
This is anti California slander 🤬
Who put a pb&j on this list. It is the only one that is a hard pass with so many others that are great.
Assuming they were all offered at the same price, I’m going lobster roll.
Ruban
LA has the best Mexican food in Mexico, tf did pbj come from?
This is impossible
What’s a fancy PB&J?
Being from Philly I’ll go with the Cheesesteak closely followed by the Chicago Beef.
Unfortunately the beat sandwich in Philly is not listed which is the Roast Pork. I like John’s the best
Leaving out Pierre’s French Dip from Los Angeles is a damn shame
Yeah
Philadelphian here voting for the cubano.
Italian Beef
Cubano. So many flavors and textures.
Missing too many sandwiches to not be rage bait. Reuben #1!
Muffuletta
Cheesesteak
Italian prosciutto and fresh mutz