Hii moved to Brooklyn from Bay Area CA… wondering if anyone knows of anywhere that sells its-it ice cream cookie sandwiches ??
by pyritevixen
29 Comments
curiouslyseekingmore
Lemme know when you find it. You can always order it online if you wanna have excess in your freezer!
c2lltq
Check out The Greene Grape grocery store in Fort Greene, they always had them when I lived in the neighborhood a couple years ago!
aidanaidanaidan
pretty sure mccarren park house has em
abertbrijs
This ain’t the bay
werdnadier
McCarren Park House in Williamsburg sells them.
Specialist-Barber320
There’s this girl Caroline on tiktok that has a series “Caroline Finds it For You” on her account @thelocavorenyc. Her post from 8/11/24 is all about looking for these! She found some at Bedford Cheese in Gramercy, Foster Sundry in Bushwick, and Court Street Grocer in Carroll Gardens. The comments list a few other locations, too.
MrMeesesPieces
What is it?
Sausage-Feet-212
foragers had them. just looked them up to find that they’ve closed. sad
Popular-Maintenance3
Bedford Cheese Shop in Gramercy has them!
thatdudepearl
You can order them in bulk on gold belly. I’m a Bay Area kid and we ordered these to be served as dessert for our wedding in NYC.
goodbyebluesky1
you want it all but you can’t have it
chargeorge
Court Street grocer in Brooklyn has them. Banging sandwiches too. Just seeing this is a nostalgia bomb. (originally from norcal, not the bay though)
As a fellow former Bay Area denizen who’s been here nearly a decade, this thread has made my day. I thought I would forever only have these when visiting my family back home.
anam3_nyc
FreshDirect used to stock them. We haven’t ordered from them in a few years, so I don’t know if it’s(-it) are still available. Good to know that there are purveyors in BK
sckreech
Is this what faith no more sang about in epic?
isuamadog
New York City Area. Fresh Direct. The Bedford Cheese Shop (Brooklyn & Manhattan). Greene Grape Provisions (Brooklyn). Pacific Standard (Brooklyn) Picolo Café (Manhattan) Foragers Market Rippers (Rockaway Beach).
Not going to help much, but as a transplant from Bay Area, I was told by a friend who went to college at Cal that there was a bar on 4th Ave Brooklyn with a CA vibe and It’s Its. We went and they were good. Not as good as when I was a kid, and a strange chaser for beer, but they were It’s Its so we were happy. The end.
Drnkz
Burlingame CA. Along with nice weather.
JoeyDardano
CLUB CLUB at Parkhouse in McCarren Park!!
Fat_Beth
Fresh direct used to carry them in a couple flavors.
jeremyfrankly
They used to have them at Pacific Standard but I don’t know if they still do, or if that place is even still around
ImmediateLychee8
They sell them at Costco in Seattle wonder if they would have them at the NY Costco locations?
Buffetline
Cappuccino for the win, I use Goldbelly.com when I am craving them. Pack sizes are big but worth it to have a freezer and summer full of them.
red_perch
Next question is where to find Dutch crutch bread!
marisaannn
McCarren Park House but don’t tell anyone
boiledeggo
This post makes me so happy
dbsfc415
San Franciscan here, I hope you find them. All flavors are good but the classic vanilla is the best.
29 Comments
Lemme know when you find it. You can always order it online if you wanna have excess in your freezer!
Check out The Greene Grape grocery store in Fort Greene, they always had them when I lived in the neighborhood a couple years ago!
pretty sure mccarren park house has em
This ain’t the bay
McCarren Park House in Williamsburg sells them.
There’s this girl Caroline on tiktok that has a series “Caroline Finds it For You” on her account @thelocavorenyc. Her post from 8/11/24 is all about looking for these! She found some at Bedford Cheese in Gramercy, Foster Sundry in Bushwick, and Court Street Grocer in Carroll Gardens. The comments list a few other locations, too.
What is it?
foragers had them. just looked them up to find that they’ve closed. sad
Bedford Cheese Shop in Gramercy has them!
You can order them in bulk on gold belly. I’m a Bay Area kid and we ordered these to be served as dessert for our wedding in NYC.
you want it all but you can’t have it
Court Street grocer in Brooklyn has them. Banging sandwiches too. Just seeing this is a nostalgia bomb. (originally from norcal, not the bay though)
[I’ve seen them at this Greenpoint grocery before but not sure if they still sell them.](https://maps.app.goo.gl/wVo6WeujzdsJEYjM7)
As a fellow former Bay Area denizen who’s been here nearly a decade, this thread has made my day. I thought I would forever only have these when visiting my family back home.
FreshDirect used to stock them. We haven’t ordered from them in a few years, so I don’t know if it’s(-it) are still available. Good to know that there are purveyors in BK
Is this what faith no more sang about in epic?
New York City Area.
Fresh Direct.
The Bedford Cheese Shop (Brooklyn & Manhattan).
Greene Grape Provisions (Brooklyn).
Pacific Standard (Brooklyn)
Picolo Café (Manhattan)
Foragers Market
Rippers (Rockaway Beach).
From here: https://www.itsiticecream.com/find-us
What’s it?
Not going to help much, but as a transplant from Bay Area, I was told by a friend who went to college at Cal that there was a bar on 4th Ave Brooklyn with a CA vibe and It’s Its. We went and they were good. Not as good as when I was a kid, and a strange chaser for beer, but they were It’s Its so we were happy. The end.
Burlingame CA. Along with nice weather.
CLUB CLUB at Parkhouse in McCarren Park!!
Fresh direct used to carry them in a couple flavors.
They used to have them at Pacific Standard but I don’t know if they still do, or if that place is even still around
They sell them at Costco in Seattle wonder if they would have them at the NY Costco locations?
Cappuccino for the win, I use Goldbelly.com when I am craving them. Pack sizes are big but worth it to have a freezer and summer full of them.
Next question is where to find Dutch crutch bread!
McCarren Park House but don’t tell anyone
This post makes me so happy
San Franciscan here, I hope you find them. All flavors are good but the classic vanilla is the best.