Is deep dish supposed to look like this? They have at least a thousand reviews and 4.5 stars, but the pizza looks burnt in several of the google photos…
by NevermindWait
27 Comments
daftstar
Was the can of better?
bassocontinubow
I’d say it looks suspicious, but I’d need to taste it. Innocent until proven guilty, in my view. It does look a bit weird though, the crust specifically.
ResponsibleFriend976
Some people will say it’s burnt others will say it’s caramelized. It’s like a Chicago pan/detroit hybrid made famous by Burt Katz. Is this from Lefty’s?
Not a crime
onlysaysisthisathing
1. Charred Quintuple Sauce
2. Dog Vomit Supreme
3. Meatball Chickpea Taco Salad Special
4. Sausage Gravy Biscuit Crust Deluxe
Expensive-Safe-6820
It doesn’t look good but it might taste good
GaryAGalindo
Downvoted, not a pizza crime. Certain Chicago Deep Dish style pizzas have more caramelized butter crusts that look burnt but actually aren’t and they are edible. They take slightly longer to cook too but the cheese closest to these “burnt” edges is divine. Yes, it’s usually under the sauce. Pequod’s in Chicago is my favorite spot.
Edit: Objection in defense of the pizza, speculation. The post flair assumes the pizza is burnt which it very well could not be.
DannySmashUp
Look, I might be high… but this looks kind of good?
The first and fourth pictures look eh, little soupy and pic one does look a little burnt (could be the lighting), but the middle two pies look perfect.
-caughtlurking-
This looks like shit. It’s a crime.
CornPuddinPops
Why not try it with your mouth instead of a court of public opinion.
ChumpNicholson
I am uh interested in that last pic
brendamrl
Is this Pequod’s? If it is, it looks sketchy but it tastes so damn good.
zml9494
That last pizza might not be a true pizza, but I can tell you I would absolutely fucking destroy that right now, goddamn all that MEATY and CHEESY goodness 🤤
datura_slurpy
Looks like Chicago style pizza. Not a crime.
Moron-Whisperer
Windy City Pie in Seattle. It’s delicious. It’s definitely not burnt. Burnt tastes bitter, that is caramelization. It tastes rich, nutty and almost buttery. Very good stuff.
HaveAtItBub
doesn’t look like pizza, should post this in casserole crimes
ingoding
Looks great, I’d try it.
joemanfisk
May not be pretty but I’m sure the pies are good
Ponjos
Did they use squid ink?
Past_Pen_4902
Out of 100?
Relevant-Emu-9741
Pequod’s in Chicago is known for this and I really want to try it!
RioTheLeoo
These don’t really resemble pizza at all to me. More like some kinds of pie or stewed dishes.
They still look pretty yummy though, so innocent, but maybe with parole
_CountMacula
Last one looked kinda good ngl and I’m from NY
Beeradleeguy
They may taste good, but the real crime here is the presentation. Does that 2nd one have carrots on it? That would certainly be criminal but the biggest offender to me is the white one, it looks like vomit on a crust.
27 Comments
Was the can of better?
I’d say it looks suspicious, but I’d need to taste it. Innocent until proven guilty, in my view. It does look a bit weird though, the crust specifically.
Some people will say it’s burnt others will say it’s caramelized. It’s like a Chicago pan/detroit hybrid made famous by Burt Katz. Is this from Lefty’s?
Not a crime
1. Charred Quintuple Sauce
2. Dog Vomit Supreme
3. Meatball Chickpea Taco Salad Special
4. Sausage Gravy Biscuit Crust Deluxe
It doesn’t look good but it might taste good
Downvoted, not a pizza crime. Certain Chicago Deep Dish style pizzas have more caramelized butter crusts that look burnt but actually aren’t and they are edible. They take slightly longer to cook too but the cheese closest to these “burnt” edges is divine. Yes, it’s usually under the sauce. Pequod’s in Chicago is my favorite spot.
Edit: Objection in defense of the pizza, speculation. The post flair assumes the pizza is burnt which it very well could not be.
Look, I might be high… but this looks kind of good?
Looks fantastic. Sorry, not a crime
Oh it’s 4.5 of 100.
https://preview.redd.it/4ho3lmaf5yqe1.jpeg?width=225&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8b4d2013aa03d79ce749ce4d4119dab2b7488e1a
The first and fourth pictures look eh, little soupy and pic one does look a little burnt (could be the lighting), but the middle two pies look perfect.
This looks like shit. It’s a crime.
Why not try it with your mouth instead of a court of public opinion.
I am uh interested in that last pic
Is this Pequod’s? If it is, it looks sketchy but it tastes so damn good.
That last pizza might not be a true pizza, but I can tell you I would absolutely fucking destroy that right now, goddamn all that MEATY and CHEESY goodness 🤤
Looks like Chicago style pizza. Not a crime.
Windy City Pie in Seattle. It’s delicious. It’s definitely not burnt. Burnt tastes bitter, that is caramelization. It tastes rich, nutty and almost buttery. Very good stuff.
doesn’t look like pizza, should post this in casserole crimes
Looks great, I’d try it.
May not be pretty but I’m sure the pies are good
Did they use squid ink?
Out of 100?
Pequod’s in Chicago is known for this and I really want to try it!
These don’t really resemble pizza at all to me. More like some kinds of pie or stewed dishes.
They still look pretty yummy though, so innocent, but maybe with parole
Last one looked kinda good ngl and I’m from NY
They may taste good, but the real crime here is the presentation. Does that 2nd one have carrots on it? That would certainly be criminal but the biggest offender to me is the white one, it looks like vomit on a crust.