I put together this map of the top 50 or so pizza spots in New York according to NYT reviews and local recommendations. It's focused on New York style, and places that serve slices, though I have included a couple that don't serve slices because of their prominence. Some spots include the recommended slice for that location. It's a work in progress though so if you think I missed a spot or have some other recommendations let me know;
https://fuhgedoughboudit.nyc/pages/new-york-city-pizza-map
by Fuhgedoughboudit