I didn’t have high expectations for the food here, but it turned out to be surprisingly good. The sliders were juicy and well seasoned, and the dumplings had a nice crisp with a juicy pork filling. I wanted to try the butterscotch pudding, which I heard is a must-order, but unfortunately it was sold out. The red cherry drink wasn’t great—too sour for my taste. The Mai Tai was decent, but the PKNA mocktail really stood out. They don’t take reservations, so seating is first come, first served.
Sunken Harbor Club: https://www.sunkenharbor.club/
If you want more details you can checkout my review: https://theblot.org/2025/04/21/nyc-hidden-bar-sunken-harbor-club-review/
by ToughIllustrator6754
17 Comments
Best tiki bar in the world.
I will fight anyone.
[removed]
You had low expectations for the food at Gage and Tollner?
Going to this bar after a top tier meal at gage and Tollner is a Biblical experience.
Looks fun – how was it, price-wise?
How long have they had food? I’ve been there a few times with no food options.
The photos of this place remind me of Inside Passage in Seattle. I wonder if there’s any connection.
The fries are some of the best I’ve had in my life
So fun getting El Diablo and hearing them do their call… then hearing it 4x more times when everyone else in the bar orders that drink 😂
I also love the carved wooden window behind the bar. It was clearly designed and made before the pandemic and the materials shortage.
Nononononobono don’t tell anyone about this the wait’s bad enough as it is. Jk. I love this place. The theming is perfect, the cocktails are inventive and interesting, the food is solid for snacking. It’s one of my favorite places to take people to
EL DIABLO!!!
This place is worth the hype. Always have a great time and love everything I get. Super fun vibe
What’s the wait like?
So, it’s an EPCOT Disney bar…. Gotcha.
Go go go!!! Such a fun time, make sure you’re there when they go into the deep!
It’s not “hidden”; it’s upstairs from the restaurant.
That looks amazing