Dining and Cooking
Thought this was a lemonade Icee at first, was really disappointed to discover it was a peeps one instead
In Stupid Food

Thought this was a lemonade Icee at first, was really disappointed to discover it was a peeps one instead


I'm trying to imagine how a marshmallow Icee would taste, and I just can't see how it would be good.

To be fair, this might just be my own bias against marshmallow or cotton candy flavorings. I'm more than willing to acknowledge that someone somewhere likes it/it isn't actually stupid ha

by LazuliArtz

25 Comments

  5. oh_io_94

    Actual stupid food on this sub? Wow. Congrats OP

  6. Sea_Cheesecake_2983

    this actually looks good ngl lol, icees are pretty much just all sugary flavors anyway. the flavor sounds interesting

  8. unicornsnake

    I had the peeps slurpee, it was actually pretty good

  9. butterdog_1

    i know it’s for the peeps branding, but what logical reason does a marshmallow flavored icee have for being neon yellow 😭 that alone is so off putting even if it does taste good

  10. Theboiledpeanut_

    Why didn’t you get a small to try and let us know man, damn.

  12. cernegiant

    I’m with you on this one. Slushies don’t have enough sour options.

  13. TechnicolorViper

    Yeah, I I bought some lemonade one time, and when I got home, it turns out it was a package of Peeps.

  15. gothdrag

    They’re not bad! They taste like cream soda to me. Too sweet to me to have a whole one though

  16. gregariousfroggy

    I feel like it would somehow have EXTRA sugar even though they’re probably all the same

  18. jimburgah

    This is for people who like it when there’s not carbonation in their soda

  19. lump-

    My kid asked for Peeps cereal at the grocery store a couple weeks ago.

    Yellow marshmallow-flavored cereal with yellow, blue, and red ass-flavored marshmallows, and enough artificial coloring to kill a water buffalo.

  21. Torbpjorn

    Put a sticker over “when lit” because this should just never be used

  22. MidnightMystique7

    Sugar with food coloring but in liquid form

  23. eddmario

    Remember the Peeps flavored Pepsi a few years back?
    I imagine that this would tast similar

Write A Comment