Gimme smore is my favorite right now, although I don’t really think it tastes much like smores to be honest.
Phish food was a fav for many years.
Oat of this swirled was my favorite about 8-9 years ago.

by ConsiderationFun7511

7 Comments

  1. team_undog

    I’m real curious about the flan flavor. Just can’t find it.

  2. MarkComprehensive798

    Totally agree with these choices. They are among the best.

  3. Ok_Transition7785

    I can’t believe you have the inferior replacement that placated no one (Oat of this Swirled) and not the original, the best Ben and Jerrys flavor ever made Oatmeal Cookie Chunk. I’m shocked, I say, shocked! Please rectify this situation immediately 😀

  4. Suitable-Tea-2065

    Phish food and Doonesbury sorbet always bring me such nostalgia. Haven’t had Phish food in at least a decade, I should pick some up. Or even better, hit up the scoop shop.

    I used to really like this cinnamon bun Ben and Jerrys, I had it a couple times and one day it just disappeared and I couldn’t find it anywhere.

  5. Plastic-Jeweler9104

    Oats of this swirled is GOAT. It’s simple and balanced with flavor.

Write A Comment