Finally tapping into my Whole Foods sale haul and it was my fiance and I’s first time trying Jeni’s! Immediate reaction was that we thought this ice cream was weirdly really salty? Did you guys feel like it was salty? It grew on me and I kept eating it but my fiance really didn’t like it and the saltiness of it 🙈
Will definitely try my other Jeni’s flavor and see how they taste! But wanted to get your guy’s opinion on Jeni’s and this flavor
by cocochanel888
10 Comments
I love peaches but I was disappointed by the amount of peach pieces in this one. I don’t think I’d buy this one again. The burnt orange dreamsicle however….
I love this flavor! Buttermilk is a salty and tangy milk I use a lot in baking and I really enjoyed that they didn’t mask the flavor with more sugar. I also really loved how the biscuit chunks taste like biscuits, not cookies, or cake, but actual biscuits which can lean more savory than sweet depending on the recipe. I know it probably isn’t for everyone but I enjoy the flavors that aren’t so sugary upfront and this is a flavor I plan ro get again next time Whole Foods has a half off sale.
This is one of my favorites along with gooey butter cake
My least favorite one lol and least flavored one i feel like
I mean the base is buttermilk, which by nature isn’t sweet and there are biscuits in it, which also aren’t sweetened, so…yeah. If you want sweet try Gooey Butter Cake, all I tasted with insulin shock.
This was also the first one I tried and I was pretty disappointed tbh
Is that a gallon?! I thought they only come in pints?
I unfortunately did not really enjoy this flavor. I knew it was going to lean salty because of the buttermilk, but the peach is what threw me off. It just tasted off… weirdly artificial and almost like alcohol. This flavor didn’t have any redeeming qualities imo, I couldn’t even finish it.
Out of curiosity, what’s your next Jeni’s flavor?? My favorite is high five candy bar.
Brown almond butter brittle is the best flavor at Jeni’s
This one is def a bit too salty for me. I like jenis flavor profiles but I’m always left feeling like I wish the mix ins were left more intact. I hate that they’re all in really small pieces and more incorporated than necessary. I want a chunk of biscuit/cake/whatever, not to feel like I’m just getting crumbs in every bite.