Do you like it? That’s all that matters. Looks delicious to me.
Alternative_Session9
Just a flex lol
jmc1278999999999
Personally I’m not a fan of fall off the bone but that doesn’t mean it’s bad. As long as it tastes good that’s all that matters. I just prefer to have the bone as a “utensil”
Timmerdogg
I never have thought about trying and now I’m ready to go to the store
Hagbard_Celine_1
For BBQ nerds? Yes. You’re setting yourself up for a bunch of “well actshuallys.” For regular people? They love some mushy ass bbq.
superbeast1983
I’d destroy this solo
Phlegm_Chowder
I came
King-James_
The McRib is back!!!
Alcarain
For competition ribs? Yeah.
For personal consumption. He’ll nah. That looks delicious.
HereForTheBoos1013
I love me some floppy ribs.
RVAPGHTOM
Your sound clip wins the internet today!
_MadSuburbanDad_
For competition, probably.
For everyone else, hellllllll no. My only problem in eating those is that I’d go so fast, I might lose a finger…
JavaGeep
They will fail in a rib competition but be a winner in my house.
KendrickBlack502
Tender, juicy meat is never a fail. Is it a little further than ideal? Maybe but everything else looks wonderful.
lockednchaste
It’s the only way my parents like them m
Discordian_Junk
Looks incredible.
HYThrowaway1980
Depends on what you like.
For me, the perfect cuisson is that you should be able to clean the rib easily with your teeth, but not be able to pull the bone out clean.
RibertarianVoter
If they came out how you wanted them, it’s not a fail.
CantaloupeAsleep502
Only a fail to people who hate good food
Terriblyboard
No not at all. TikTok is for losers. I prefer to do mine were they are just nearly falling off the bone and you can pull them out like that. You can do it without being all mushy. It is past were they normally take a “competition rib”. Also you can make mcribs at home with the left over racks.
ns5oh
I’d have no problem with this
muscle_thumbs
Everyone has their own opinions when it comes to BBQ. If your family likes it that’s a win in my book. I like STLs better than BBs and I rather eat a fat ribeye than a brisket.
JamWams
I love fall of the bone bbq so it’s a win for me
Far_Zone_9512
It matters if you like them like that. Personally, I don’t like fall off the bone… but to each his own.
notdrewcarrey
May get some flack for this, but too many people who do home bbq think they’re in a competition. Just make good bbq. If you, your family, and friends enjoy it, great.
Like others have said, you don’t want them to fall off the bone. However, did they still taste good? Did you enjoy them?
Enjoy cooking and the time spent with family and friends.
chillfi420
Not if that’s the way you like it but pork shoulder is much cheaper if you want fall off the bone style meat.
KarmalizedTaco
I’ve seen fall off the bone, but I ain’t ever seen fall out da rib!
mason729
the platonic mcrib
blkkice77
The real McRib!
dremag2009
Bone in or out, looks delicious to me. Enjoy!
Heavymetal-714
Yeah it is. Send them here and I’ll dispose of them properly.
Historical-Listen102
I’d love this- OP would you mind posting your recipe?
MagazineDelicious151
I would have no problem with that and they look great but I respect what others are saying as well.
mightyarrow
For comp standards, yes. And that’s it.
That is it. I’d eat that in a heartbeat.
Kiagowhoosh
It’s all about preference. I like it when the bones slide out and or fall off the bone.
DemDave
Would it do well in a competition? No.
Will it still be tasty as heck? Yes.
Only a fail if *you* don’t like it.
brutusx00
I would get a big ass loaf of Italian bread and just put that whole slab on it with some coleslaw. That’s the best and biggest McRib you will ever find.
deceptivekhan
I like a little chew left in my ribs, but as long as the smoke and rub are on point I ain’t complaining.
tattoodlez
In competition that is overcooked. At my house, that is just right.
AngryTrunkMonkey
That’d make a killer McRib!
IconTactical
I’ll be fall-off-the-bone ribs until the day I’ve died. Yes, we get it, they’re overcooked and you’d lose in a competition. I’ve had them both ways and I’ll always prefer them this way.
A_SimpleThought
As someone who has just stumbled on this sub Reddit, can someone fill me in on what is perceived to be wrong here?
TheTimePolice710
Debone, cut into chunks that fit your bread, add Pickles onion and sauce. Fuck competition nerds lol this shit slaps
tgruener
It‘s nice to see that Reddit has gotten more reasonable over the years. I still can remember those times when BBQ snobs wrote a lot of shit about tender rib meat that fell off the bone.
lowandslow86
Perfect..not super fall off the bone.
slindner1985
They look good. They arent falling apart. You can pull the bone out but it isn’t shredding like paper
Underwater_Karma
Why are you asking Reddit if you enjoyed your ribs?
ReallyThisGuyAgain
“Look at me!” Has permeated every sum I guess.
Naughty_old_guy_69
Yes only by competition standards But that doesn’t mean they won’t be excellent.
50 Comments
Mmmmm. Fuck no.
Do you like it? That’s all that matters. Looks delicious to me.
Just a flex lol
Personally I’m not a fan of fall off the bone but that doesn’t mean it’s bad. As long as it tastes good that’s all that matters. I just prefer to have the bone as a “utensil”
I never have thought about trying and now I’m ready to go to the store
For BBQ nerds? Yes. You’re setting yourself up for a bunch of “well actshuallys.” For regular people? They love some mushy ass bbq.
I’d destroy this solo
I came
The McRib is back!!!
For competition ribs? Yeah.
For personal consumption. He’ll nah. That looks delicious.
I love me some floppy ribs.
Your sound clip wins the internet today!
For competition, probably.
For everyone else, hellllllll no. My only problem in eating those is that I’d go so fast, I might lose a finger…
They will fail in a rib competition but be a winner in my house.
Tender, juicy meat is never a fail. Is it a little further than ideal? Maybe but everything else looks wonderful.
It’s the only way my parents like them m
Looks incredible.
Depends on what you like.
For me, the perfect cuisson is that you should be able to clean the rib easily with your teeth, but not be able to pull the bone out clean.
If they came out how you wanted them, it’s not a fail.
Only a fail to people who hate good food
No not at all. TikTok is for losers. I prefer to do mine were they are just nearly falling off the bone and you can pull them out like that. You can do it without being all mushy. It is past were they normally take a “competition rib”. Also you can make mcribs at home with the left over racks.
I’d have no problem with this
Everyone has their own opinions when it comes to BBQ. If your family likes it that’s a win in my book. I like STLs better than BBs and I rather eat a fat ribeye than a brisket.
I love fall of the bone bbq so it’s a win for me
It matters if you like them like that. Personally, I don’t like fall off the bone… but to each his own.
May get some flack for this, but too many people who do home bbq think they’re in a competition. Just make good bbq. If you, your family, and friends enjoy it, great.
Like others have said, you don’t want them to fall off the bone. However, did they still taste good? Did you enjoy them?
Enjoy cooking and the time spent with family and friends.
Not if that’s the way you like it but pork shoulder is much cheaper if you want fall off the bone style meat.
I’ve seen fall off the bone, but I ain’t ever seen fall out da rib!
the platonic mcrib
The real McRib!
Bone in or out, looks delicious to me. Enjoy!
Yeah it is. Send them here and I’ll dispose of them properly.
I’d love this- OP would you mind posting your recipe?
I would have no problem with that and they look great but I respect what others are saying as well.
For comp standards, yes. And that’s it.
That is it. I’d eat that in a heartbeat.
It’s all about preference. I like it when the bones slide out and or fall off the bone.
Would it do well in a competition? No.
Will it still be tasty as heck? Yes.
Only a fail if *you* don’t like it.
I would get a big ass loaf of Italian bread and just put that whole slab on it with some coleslaw. That’s the best and biggest McRib you will ever find.
I like a little chew left in my ribs, but as long as the smoke and rub are on point I ain’t complaining.
In competition that is overcooked. At my house, that is just right.
That’d make a killer McRib!
I’ll be fall-off-the-bone ribs until the day I’ve died. Yes, we get it, they’re overcooked and you’d lose in a competition. I’ve had them both ways and I’ll always prefer them this way.
As someone who has just stumbled on this sub Reddit, can someone fill me in on what is perceived to be wrong here?
Debone, cut into chunks that fit your bread, add Pickles onion and sauce. Fuck competition nerds lol this shit slaps
It‘s nice to see that Reddit has gotten more reasonable over the years. I still can remember those times when BBQ snobs wrote a lot of shit about tender rib meat that fell off the bone.
Perfect..not super fall off the bone.
They look good. They arent falling apart. You can pull the bone out but it isn’t shredding like paper
Why are you asking Reddit if you enjoyed your ribs?
“Look at me!” Has permeated every sum I guess.
Yes only by competition standards
But that doesn’t mean they won’t be excellent.