I know it’s been said before, but this flavor is just so freaking good. What’s funny is that I don’t like buttercream frosting and always scrape it off my cake/cupcake but THIS is just the BEST.
And the best part is that a little bit takes my sweet cravings away so the pint lasts awhile! The cake chunks are perfect too.
by IDunnoReallyIDont
14 Comments
Cream shot!
I love love love birthday cake flavored anything but i absolutely hated this ice cream. It was too sweet. So sweet it was thrown away.
Glad that this sub loves it. I must be alone.
My guess was Jenis when I saw that first photo.
It’s honestly SO good but I *really* don’t like “Birthday Cake” flavored ice cream.
There’s a reason I’m an ice cream person not a cake person.
Ugh this is 1/2 sprinkles. Cloyingly sweet wax. Like taking a spoonful of sprinkles/jimmies.
Still better than the artificially-flavored Blue Bell BS most people post here.
This is my go-to during that time of the month ♥️
Glad you liked it. To me it was very bland and overly sweet. My least favorite Jeni’s.
Is it super sweet? I want a good birthday cake flavor but often find them teeth ache-ingly sugary.
I do love this. What are your other top three? (Figuring I might gain inspiration!)
did you get this in Ny? _~_
Am I the only one that none of the jenny’s flavors look remotely appetizing? AlrightI have not tried any
If you have Graeters by you you need to try theirs, it’s even better 😱
this is borderline sickly sweet for me but it’s probably the most accurate birthday cake flavor I’ve ever had lol. it’s incredibly rich and i can only manage a few bites at a time. it legit tastes exactly like eating an ice cream cake with the frosting. i don’t think I’d repurchase it despite how good it is bc it’s so overpowering so im still on the hunt for the perfect bday cake flavor !
I’ve had nothing but bad experiences with “birthday cake” flavored things. They always taste so sweet to the point of just tasting like chemicals.
I admit that does look so tasty though.