Never tried Melinda’s, but aware of all the hate…are any of these good?
These were gifted to me. Just wondering if any of these are actually good. I’ve seen so many negative reviews on this brand and was just wondering what are some opinions on these.
by TazzleMcBuggins
40 Comments
Live_Mastodon_5922
The ones in the glass bottles are better than any of the ones you have there
Acceptable_Listen740
Fire roasted garlic habanero is my daily go to
Froqwasket
Ghost pepper sauce is great. Melinda’s is popular on here
Spaceman_Spliff_42
Melinda’s sauces are among my favorite go-to condiments. I’m not aware of hate for them
Radical_Joe
Melinda slaps. If you can find the ghost pepper hot honey buy multiple! Excellent for pizza
tweedchemtrailblazer
Ghost pepper is good. The others are okay.
GobiBall
The green and hot mustard are my favorite.
FjordExplorer
Missed the best one, Ghost Pepper Wing Sauce.
jakesdrool05
Not a fan of any of them.
TG_Iceman
Mexicana is their best sauce
TorrenceMightingale
I hate bottom right if anyone wants a nearly full bottle of the green.
twitchismental
All the hate?? Melindas is usually talked about positively on this board. With that said that green sauce is delicious… As is the Jalapeno Ketchup.
ArlendmcFarland
The one on the bottom left is good
cuentalternativa
I haven’t tried the other ketchups but the jalapeño one is really great
mayan_monkey
The garlic ghost pepper and the habanero mustard are my favorite.
king_england
Melinda’s is great. Some of em aren’t very good—I don’t care for their take on green sauce—but everything else is excellent. The cayenne-habanero wing sauce in particular.
ImpressionSilver9529
Ive tried a lot of their hot sauces and wing sauces. I have no complaints and continue to buy their wing sauce especially. Its ridiculous on breaded chicken strips. It burns my whole mouth off and intestines but it tastes too good to care lol.
Have never seen the ketchup. Not a fan of spicy ketchup. I would just slather the fries in their wing sauce if I wanted spicy fries.
homer_simpin
I’ve never tried their ketchup but have liked every melinda’s sauce I tried. The ghost pepper is a personal favorite
karl_hungas
Brother you own them, they are in your kitchen and you’re standing over them. TRY THEM AND TELL US
xeynx
I’ve used the ghost pepper ketchup to make cocktail sauce and that turned out really good.
pjb1999
I think Melinda’s hot sauces are really good. I’ve tried several and liked them all.
dream_of_the_night
I think the Sriracha is great as a wing sauce.
AL-KINDA
i love the ghost pepper for wings. just dont over do it.
milksasquatch
I absolutely love the ghost pepper ketchup. It tastes kind of like Arby’s sauce, but more ketchupy and spicy. Def some cloves in the mix.
sirnutzaIot
Their ketchups are awesome. I always have some of the ghost or habanero, the flavors great on both but I might like hab more
Grouchy_Tap_8264
Yes, all of Marie Sharp’s recipe are awesome. Melinda’s is the stolen brand. If you want opinion on taste then go to The Belizean. Melinda WAS distributer in U.S., but fuckwits got gready and stole, then used less ripe Peppers and mucked it up.
matejoojuu
You have them infront of you. That being said, for me it doesnt matter how they taste as they are a stolen product.
Neither-Bluebird-755
The creamy ghost pepper wing sauce is my go-to for lunch every single day. It’s not one of the ones in your photo though.
AShotgunNamedMarcus
I like the ghost ketchup and they also have a honey mustard that is pretty fantastic.
Baddog789
I got a bottle of lower left ghost pepper. I haven’t opened it yet so no help but I’ll be watching the comments.
StevieBeetz
This is a hot sauce sub why does everyone hate when hot sauce is spicy!?
Careless-Pizza-7328
That’s a lifetime supply of ketchup for me.
R_A_H
The best Melinda’s I’ve had came in glass bottles.
Most_Chapter_424
Go find their hot honey mustard, I put it on everything
GuyAskAlot22
The best is the pizza hot sauce. Have not been able to find it other than sample packs.
Ringadean
They’re literally right in front of you
spenghali
The green sauce is one of my staples
themayorhere
The ghost pepper is solid. The ketchups are great. I think I like the Heinz Jalapeño better tho
40 Comments
The ones in the glass bottles are better than any of the ones you have there
Fire roasted garlic habanero is my daily go to
Ghost pepper sauce is great. Melinda’s is popular on here
Melinda’s sauces are among my favorite go-to condiments. I’m not aware of hate for them
Melinda slaps. If you can find the ghost pepper hot honey buy multiple! Excellent for pizza
Ghost pepper is good. The others are okay.
The green and hot mustard are my favorite.
Missed the best one, Ghost Pepper Wing Sauce.
Not a fan of any of them.
Mexicana is their best sauce
I hate bottom right if anyone wants a nearly full bottle of the green.
All the hate?? Melindas is usually talked about positively on this board. With that said that green sauce is delicious… As is the Jalapeno Ketchup.
The one on the bottom left is good
I haven’t tried the other ketchups but the jalapeño one is really great
The garlic ghost pepper and the habanero mustard are my favorite.
Melinda’s is great. Some of em aren’t very good—I don’t care for their take on green sauce—but everything else is excellent. The cayenne-habanero wing sauce in particular.
Ive tried a lot of their hot sauces and wing sauces. I have no complaints and continue to buy their wing sauce especially. Its ridiculous on breaded chicken strips. It burns my whole mouth off and intestines but it tastes too good to care lol.
Have never seen the ketchup. Not a fan of spicy ketchup. I would just slather the fries in their wing sauce if I wanted spicy fries.
I’ve never tried their ketchup but have liked every melinda’s sauce I tried. The ghost pepper is a personal favorite
Brother you own them, they are in your kitchen and you’re standing over them. TRY THEM AND TELL US
I’ve used the ghost pepper ketchup to make cocktail sauce and that turned out really good.
I think Melinda’s hot sauces are really good. I’ve tried several and liked them all.
I think the Sriracha is great as a wing sauce.
i love the ghost pepper for wings. just dont over do it.
I absolutely love the ghost pepper ketchup. It tastes kind of like Arby’s sauce, but more ketchupy and spicy. Def some cloves in the mix.
Their ketchups are awesome. I always have some of the ghost or habanero, the flavors great on both but I might like hab more
Yes, all of Marie Sharp’s recipe are awesome. Melinda’s is the stolen brand. If you want opinion on taste then go to The Belizean. Melinda WAS distributer in U.S., but fuckwits got gready and stole, then used less ripe Peppers and mucked it up.
You have them infront of you. That being said, for me it doesnt matter how they taste as they are a stolen product.
The creamy ghost pepper wing sauce is my go-to for lunch every single day. It’s not one of the ones in your photo though.
I like the ghost ketchup and they also have a honey mustard that is pretty fantastic.
I got a bottle of lower left ghost pepper. I haven’t opened it yet so no help but I’ll be watching the comments.
This is a hot sauce sub why does everyone hate when hot sauce is spicy!?
That’s a lifetime supply of ketchup for me.
The best Melinda’s I’ve had came in glass bottles.
Go find their hot honey mustard, I put it on everything
The best is the pizza hot sauce. Have not been able to find it other than sample packs.
They’re literally right in front of you
The green sauce is one of my staples
The ghost pepper is solid. The ketchups are great. I think I like the Heinz Jalapeño better tho
Ghost pepper ketchup is banging on a burger
that jalapeño ketchup is golden