I added water instead of milk and it didn’t thicken up at all

by Turbulent_Age3152

30 Comments

  1. Individual-Bed-7708

    That’s because you don’t make Alfredo sauce in the oven

  2. YamContent1662

    How it suppose to thicken up without a binding agent other than our thoughts and prayers

  3. caelum_daemon

    You know the chicken releases juice too right?

  4. trampus1

    Better put it back in, that top piece doesn’t look cooked very well.

  5. dannydavithoe

    This should be the sub’s mascot imo, whatever this is good Lord.

  6. ArdraMercury

    alfredo sauce is literally butter, garlic, parmesan and heavy cream. not that hard tbh

  7. pockets3d

    One of those things I would have ate and never told a soul.

    Worse things happen at sea.

  8. AmericanSpeller

    Are the skins still on the onions???

  9. Zeldabacon64

    Could you add some more white to the dish maybe?

  10. PetuniaDragon

    I don’t even know what to say lol but I definitely would not eat this

  11. Was this raw chicken in a jar of store bought sauce?

  12. RalphWaldoPickleCh1p

    This is food poisoning waiting to happen with that pink chicken.

  13. DrNinnuxx

    I would have used a slow cooker and made the sauce ahead of time.

  14. Endlesstrash1337

    You added water, traditionally used to thin stuff out, to thicken a sauce? WAT

  15. MyNameIsSkittles

    I am not personally a fan of recipes but at least I can acknowledge their usefulness for some people. In this case, please learn how to follow one.

    Also common sense – water can not be a substitute for milk in sauces

  16. Curious-Ad-7977

    I’m beginning to remember why I had to unfollow this page in my first trimester sick everyday lmfao, this looks absolutely foul

  17. GirthyPigeon

    Putting massive hunks of onion in a baked pasta sauce is not a smart idea. Also, Alfredo is nothing but butter, parmesan cheese, pepper and pasta with a bit of pasta water.

  18. You and the “soup” guy from the other post should meet and discuss what sauces and soups should look like

  19. littleclaww

    You can save this… possibly.

    Separate chicken and onions from the liquid. On your stove, melt some butter. Finely dice your onions and throw them in to let them caramelize a bit. When they get some color on them, add flour to your onion and butter mixture. You want to cook on medium and constantly whisk it to make a roux. The roux is what makes Alfredo thick. You want to cook it long enough it cooks off the flour flavor, but do not let it burn or get too dark. After a few minutes, slowly add in your liquid while whisking constantly. You want to add it slow to ensure your sauce does not have any lumps. Let this sauce simmer for a bit, add any seasoning if it’s bland. Stir occasionally.

    While this simmers, dice up your chicken. Boil some pasta if you want it. Once the sauce thickens to your liking, serve it over the diced chicken and pasta.