I am officially obsessed with Sally and her recipes! I bought her book and my chocolate loving husband asked if I could make this pie for him. He helped me throughout the process (mostly for bragging rights 😆) and we produced the pie in a few short hours. I can’t wait to cut into it after it chills for a few more hours.

by EATokich

19 Comments

  1. priscila179

    This looks like the perfect crust after when my kids “eat Oreos” they only have the filling and toss the cookies 🤣

  2. michaelaaa96

    Don’t be shy, show us the cut section

  3. Disneyhorse

    I would like to see a slice when you serve it. It looks amazing and I love Sally’s recipes (I’ve got her coconut macadamia cookies dough chilling in the fridge as we speak). Haven’t made that pie but you’re inspiring me.

  4. mynamesleslie

    I made this last thanksgiving and it was a hit! Highly recommend for the chocolate lovers out there.

    The only thing I would change in the future is I would skip the middle layer of Oreo crumbs. Every slice we cut fell apart at that layer and it wasn’t really necessary.

  5. vintageideals

    I love mile high pies!!!! Looks great!!

  6. cloomis

    I’m making this Friday for our 14 year wedding anniversary!

  7. br4tygirl

    OH GOD PLEASE LET US KNOW HOW IT COMES OUT BC I WILL MAKE IT IMMEDIATELY

  8. caramelgelatto

    I love Sally! This looks delicious! You did an amazing job 🩷

  9. OkCryptographer1922

    Is this the same sally as the one that always pops up no matter what recipe I search?

  10. missvbee

    Can I come over for a slice? Want this so bad right now (9mo pregnant)