I tried to make Frankenstein Kitchen Sink cookies but I used browned butter and they came out looking like “what you clean out of a kitchen drain” cookies.
They taste great though!
Edit: Thanks for the love everyone! I was not expecting it, but I appreciate it so much! For those asking, the recipe is here. I tried to turn it into Halloween from Christmas. I browned the butter and didn't use pretzels, so I added more Reese's, chocolate chips, and potato chips. I also found the eyeball sprinkles at Superstore (I'm from Canada) and just stuck them in thee melted chocolate right out of the oven. I also added about 1/4 teaspoon of the green food dye into the wet ingredients. I think they could be a brighter green without browning the butter and adding the food dye to the dry ingredients.
Thanks again for the love! <3
by Last_Thursday
36 Comments
I like yours better! The green is much more natural and palatable to me than the slime color in the original. And the eyes are cute!
glad they taste good! i think they’re cute though 🥺
They’re so cute!!! Where did you get the lil eyeball sprinkles btw 🥺 this is so not a fail babe be nicer to yourself…
Honestly, yours look way cooler
Yours look better and more Halloweeny. The eyes really make them stand out. The first pic looks like it has a filter on it too, so it’s hard to judge what their color really is.
They’re adorable!
Yours looks more “Halloweenee,” imho, since it looks like some blob from a swamp that integrates parts of the environment into itself. While the first picture are just ordinary chocolate chip cookies, that are dyed green.
Or some kind of moss monster maybe 🤔 they look great.
I like yours a lot more! It’s so cute.
I like yours way better. I’d buy them over the first
I think yours look better! Reminds me of Slimer from Ghostbusters.
Yours look so much cuter and more like a fun Halloween treat! I think you one upped the original.
It looks like you put some monsters through a meat grinder or food processor so they’re very on brand and are more interesting and fun looking than the OG recipe.
I like it… it’s more like a swamp-thing blob consuming everything it touches… or that Goosebumps book where the gelatinous blob starts eating everything in the neighborhood… i’d eat those… they look goooooood af…
Yours look so good though!!
Yours look way better, imo.
Yours look way cuter!
Yours look way better than the inspo and more Halloweeny.
Yours are way better! The other ones just look like green chocolate chip cookies, yours look more Halloweeny and Frankensteiny
Definitely yours!!! They’re brilliant
Your cookies are awesome!! They are definitely better than the first.
Can you share the recipe?
Yours are much better!
I prefer your version. Better color and creepier. Most likely tastes better too!
Those are pretty cute actually! I like how they look better than the inspiration pic
Urs look better to me
Very spooky! 🎃
There may be a little too much flour in them and/or the water that evaporated out of the butter stopped them from spreading a little bit.
Call them Oscar the grouch cookies!
Yours look great! Also, the image on the left is edited/filtered. They are probably the color yours are!
don’t be so hard on yourself, i think they look good. Better than the original, even
I’d so much rather eat yours then the originals. That hyper green color doesn’t look appetizing at all to me, and yours look way more fun and Halloween themed. The first ones look like they could be simple mint chip cookies without context.
Ed…ward…
Green cookies? I juuuuusssst might make some today
i like yours better!! they look like an amalgamation in the most charming spooky way lol
Don’t worry, I’m on my way to take them off of your hands.
You really can’t go wrong with Reese’s pieces in a cookie either.
Yours looks more Frankenstein-y! I like it
I think yours look **much** better – they don’t have that over tinted color. What they **do** have is Reese’s. And **eyeballs!** That’s definitely more “Frankensteinish”, IMHO! **Not** a fail!