Five Star Bar has been a favorite for years and this feels like it came out of nowhere. Their food and vibes were 10/10 for me and everyone I brought there, so I simply don't understand! If any of the staff see this, we love you all!

by desktopdrummer

21 Comments

  1. chicagojoe1979

    The staff were great; everything else was sliding badly.

  2. JnyBlkLabel

    Well, they were more than half empty basically every single day…and had zero identity since re-opening.

  3. Substantial-Age-8097

    Damn. This place was one of my faves in the late aughts.

  4. Damn, did they still have the awning from 1056?

  5. booshayed

    Brutal service and basically no one else there the three times I’ve gone this year probably will do it

  6. GardenKeep

    They had the original Pontiac cafe sign. Wonder what will happen to it.

  7. Where_is_Wallace

    Damn they had a decent Detroit style pizza. Maybe not the best but nice for a neighborhood spot

  8. Every single time I went there it felt like I was inconveniencing the staff by being there. I’m not surprised

  9. kennyloftor

    for seconds i thought my beloved gold star bar had closed

  10. ChoppyChug

    Such a shame, I ate there about 4 years ago when I first moved to the city. The pizza was absolutely phenomenal, I loved it.

    Then I got some friends about a year ago to go back with me, and I was hyping them up for this fantastic pizza.

    The quality had dipped so severely, I was embarrassed to have brought my friends.

  11. CaptainJackKevorkian

    they did some posh redesign of the space post-covid and it never felt the same to me

  12. Qtarant777

    Poor redesign. No marketing. Staff was always acting like they were too busy. Food was subpar. Not surprised. Hopefully a good neighborhood spot comes in there

  13. Pretty much gutted a very unique and personal feeling bar to make it comfy to appeal to a clientele who couldn’t care less. Personally, the treatment of staff once the new ownership really rubbed me the wrong way, and I never stepped foot inside.

  14. I just remember a bartender texting the whole time I was there. I had to go up to him to ask for a drink.

  15. That_Walk_6568

    They used to have some great food but that and the service seemed to have crashed in the last 3-4 years.

  16. yer_moms_reddit69

    Turns out the five stars, was outta ten!

  17. CrocsSportello

    Ownership stealing tips, poor service, weird vibes, expensive drinks.

  18. GMHammondEsquire

    I’ve never heard of it and I eat out every day.