Thoughts on this one from Tillamook? I like it… but can’t say I’m blown away.
Thoughts on this one from Tillamook? I like it… but can’t say I’m blown away.
by jesssssssee
21 Comments
Triumvph
Meh! Cheap with a ton of air mixed in.
Available-Guava5515
Seems like this one disappointed just about everybody. I was underwhelmed too
FriendStunning5399
It’s all emulsifiers
HVAC_instructor
I would not ever see myself picking that one. But thanks for doing the advance work so that I know not to be tempted in the future
honeysesamechicken
So underwhelming. We tossed it after trying to eat it several times.
hopple_popple
I wish they brought back the peppermint bark ice cream instead.
WickedlyWitty
I wonder why they changed the name. It used to be Holiday sugar cookie, with a snowflake cookie on the front
BuildingBetterBack
That’s the only Tillamook I wouldn’t get again. They could make the limited edition espresso chip permanent though
heretoimprovethings
Tillamook always leaves me disappointed.
7805660444
The other limited edition flavor, espresso chip is really good
BustThaScientifical
I like their cheese, not so much a fan of the ice cream. Odd texture.
condaleza_rice
Saw the negative reviews on here, but tried this one on sale anyway. Loved it! Super creamy and the sugar crystals were fun and different
LobsterLovingLlama
I’m in the never again group when it comes to Tillamook
o0-o0-
Whew, looks like I chose correctly! Now to make sure I did indeed buy espresso chip.
AshenHunter42
Boycotted years ago. I’m a ice cream snob and everyone would be like “it’s just the best” no it’s garbage and the mix ins ha don’t even get me started
Upbeat_Activity8147
This was terrible. The flavor did not come through, the cookie dough pieces were hard and dry and the cookies pieces were weirdly not cookie pieces. I like sweet things, but there wasn’t even a hint of vanilla or other taste of any kind. So disappointing. Just wanted a cookie dough that wasn’t ruined by chocolate chips.
txvetko
I just tried that one last night! Pretty disappointing. I may save it to use instead of vanilla on top of baked goods like apple pie, but I won’t be wasting calories on that as a stand-alone dessert.
potatoguy
Its gross. The big sugar grains turn me off. Oh the taste sucks too
Puzzle-Peep
Not a fan. Too gritty.
MarkComprehensive798
Got it last year and was also very disappointed. I pretty much swore off Tillamook after this one and the apple crisp one.
Ok_Transition7785
Hard no on Tillamook for me, terrible consistency and a paucity of mix ins.
21 Comments
Meh! Cheap with a ton of air mixed in.
Seems like this one disappointed just about everybody. I was underwhelmed too
It’s all emulsifiers
I would not ever see myself picking that one. But thanks for doing the advance work so that I know not to be tempted in the future
So underwhelming. We tossed it after trying to eat it several times.
I wish they brought back the peppermint bark ice cream instead.
I wonder why they changed the name. It used to be Holiday sugar cookie, with a snowflake cookie on the front
That’s the only Tillamook I wouldn’t get again. They could make the limited edition espresso chip permanent though
Tillamook always leaves me disappointed.
The other limited edition flavor, espresso chip is really good
I like their cheese, not so much a fan of the ice cream. Odd texture.
Saw the negative reviews on here, but tried this one on sale anyway. Loved it! Super creamy and the sugar crystals were fun and different
I’m in the never again group when it comes to Tillamook
Whew, looks like I chose correctly! Now to make sure I did indeed buy espresso chip.
Boycotted years ago. I’m a ice cream snob and everyone would be like “it’s just the best” no it’s garbage and the mix ins ha don’t even get me started
This was terrible. The flavor did not come through, the cookie dough pieces were hard and dry and the cookies pieces were weirdly not cookie pieces. I like sweet things, but there wasn’t even a hint of vanilla or other taste of any kind. So disappointing. Just wanted a cookie dough that wasn’t ruined by chocolate chips.
I just tried that one last night! Pretty disappointing. I may save it to use instead of vanilla on top of baked goods like apple pie, but I won’t be wasting calories on that as a stand-alone dessert.
Its gross. The big sugar grains turn me off. Oh the taste sucks too
Not a fan. Too gritty.
Got it last year and was also very disappointed. I pretty much swore off Tillamook after this one and the apple crisp one.
Hard no on Tillamook for me, terrible consistency and a paucity of mix ins.