I usually do but the topped ones are sooo rich. I found this flavor and reminded me of home (NY) because it tasted like a black and white cookie with the chocolate ganache. 9/10 absolutely buying again!
by AdministrativeEnd168
45 Comments
Gbuono22
I always eat the entire pint unless I’m really being good.
rotbath
If I’m in luteal, you betcha.
84th_legislature
i try to do my pints in thirds, but if i’m in luteal or the gummy hit, all bets are off
Fine-Subject-5832
Basic flavor yes usually within an evening something wild 2-3 nights.
StrangeAir6637
never eaten a whole pint in one go, i prefer to take a few bites each day, over the course of 2-3 weeks
nervous__chemist
I usually eat in thirds or halves… for these kind of topped ones I usually end up just tossing most of the top though lol
litmusfest
I’ve never finished one in one sitting. As a kid I always had to just take 2-3 scoops in a bowl. My friend introduced me to eating straight out of the pint as an adult and even that feels so decadent, but the max I can have is probably half at once and that’s if I’m high.
S_Miami
I have a rule that I can’t finish in 1 go. But I absolutely could.
I try for thirds. But I usually end up eating 1/3 to start, then the remaining 2/3. Because I’ll get to the end of the second third and think “what the hell”.
kevnmartin
With that one, I would!
SlammedZero
Hell yeah I do…..but I have no self-control, so……..
Lol
HovercraftSudden7895
I usually eat a few bites until my mouth is cold and then I stop because I can’t enjoy it when my mouth is too cold
Rare-Insect7173
I’m either eating none of it or all of it
Motor-Drama-1421
Never finished a whole pint even at my fattest, just get sick of things soon enough, but this is the first im hearing of this flavor and it looks crazy to me, im gonna find it
winteriscoming9099
I could finish any pint in one go. But for my own sake, I max out at half a pint.
extrablessing
Nope. Takes me probably a week plus.
cucucachooo
A pint lasts me 3 or 4 weeks.
SnackForagers
One minimum, usually two
Bunnnnii
Is there another way? It’s just a pint!
latestnightowl
How does this one compare with Jeni’s Boston Cream Pie flavor for anyone who has had both?
No_Problem_9840
ah!! I love Boston cream and I also want to be the third person to say luteal
FriendStunning5399
I’ve eaten two pints in a sitting three times. I ate three in one day once. Every time I get a pint I eat it in one go.
LouisRitter
When I’m running a caloric deficit for months I’ll down one no problem but typically would try to do 2-3. Now the low sugar, low fat options are no holds barred.
Capable_Coconut6211
I ususally it a little bit at a time but I did finish off brownie core ice cream today. 😋
Available-Guava5515
It’s just too many calories to finish it in a sitting. I go for thirds.
RockiestRaccoon
Shit, maybe when I was a lil younger but hell no. That’s like 1200 calories of ice cream 😭
Chunkydowapp
One and done for me. Im proud of everyone else who has self control Good for you guys
leelee1976
No but only cause the ice cream melts more than I like in the time it takes to eat the pint. I usually do half or 2/3
j00lie
Honestly I haven’t eaten an entire pint in like fifteen years. If I’m buying a pint it’ll last like 4-6 servings. Buuuut if I go to an ice cream shop and they happen to give me a pint of ice cream as their double scoop… I can’t say I wouldn’t finish it on the spot
blacknightbluesky
I heard that at the Ben and Jerry’s factory they tell you a pint is one serving size lol.
RidiculousBadger
As opposed to what? So confused by your question.
Possible-Ranger3072
I have before but I try not to make a habit of it. But I also won’t deny myself that either 😌
nightwolves
This flavor was so gross to me! The chocolate tasted like plastic chemical trash, this was sent right into the trash
DangerDragonXCV
The only time I haven’t been able to finish a pint was after finishing the first one
stormking14
Its going down no questions asked lol
Project_ARTICHOKE
The only time I ever finished a whole pint was 8 months pregnant
allout2025
Yes lol I always do and love this flavor too. Sometimes half. But usually the entire
RedbangzOF
Imma for real eat all of this flavor! 😋
iwannabefamouss
I loveeeee this flavor but no never in one go
-PrincessPumpkin-
I ate an entire pint in one sitting twice in one week, then never again haha. I hated how bloated I felt the next day. But could I? Absolutely!
vixenstarlet1949
i usually eat 1/3 of it in one sitting. i’ve been really into having thee scoops of different ice creams, so they last longer that way too :]
Justyouraverageshmo
I did once and threw up. but to be fair it was quart sized
personwriter
Many times.
That’s more the norm than the exception. I’m also quite active, so that helps, ha!
FishyRaisin668
Pretty much always in one sitting, yup
Purple_IsA_Flavor
No but the first time I buy it there’s an excellent chance it will happen
tulipskull
It’s been a hot minute since I could house a whole pint of ice cream in one sitting. Makes my stomach hurt, and I usually get sick of the sweetness after about 1/3 of the pint anyways
45 Comments
I always eat the entire pint unless I’m really being good.
If I’m in luteal, you betcha.
i try to do my pints in thirds, but if i’m in luteal or the gummy hit, all bets are off
Basic flavor yes usually within an evening something wild 2-3 nights.
never eaten a whole pint in one go, i prefer to take a few bites each day, over the course of 2-3 weeks
I usually eat in thirds or halves… for these kind of topped ones I usually end up just tossing most of the top though lol
I’ve never finished one in one sitting. As a kid I always had to just take 2-3 scoops in a bowl. My friend introduced me to eating straight out of the pint as an adult and even that feels so decadent, but the max I can have is probably half at once and that’s if I’m high.
I have a rule that I can’t finish in 1 go. But I absolutely could.
I try for thirds. But I usually end up eating 1/3 to start, then the remaining 2/3. Because I’ll get to the end of the second third and think “what the hell”.
With that one, I would!
Hell yeah I do…..but I have no self-control, so……..
Lol
I usually eat a few bites until my mouth is cold and then I stop because I can’t enjoy it when my mouth is too cold
I’m either eating none of it or all of it
Never finished a whole pint even at my fattest, just get sick of things soon enough, but this is the first im hearing of this flavor and it looks crazy to me, im gonna find it
I could finish any pint in one go. But for my own sake, I max out at half a pint.
Nope. Takes me probably a week plus.
A pint lasts me 3 or 4 weeks.
One minimum, usually two
Is there another way? It’s just a pint!
How does this one compare with Jeni’s Boston Cream Pie flavor for anyone who has had both?
ah!! I love Boston cream and I also want to be the third person to say luteal
I’ve eaten two pints in a sitting three times. I ate three in one day once. Every time I get a pint I eat it in one go.
When I’m running a caloric deficit for months I’ll down one no problem but typically would try to do 2-3. Now the low sugar, low fat options are no holds barred.
I ususally it a little bit at a time but I did finish off brownie core ice cream today. 😋
It’s just too many calories to finish it in a sitting. I go for thirds.
Shit, maybe when I was a lil younger but hell no. That’s like 1200 calories of ice cream 😭
One and done for me. Im proud of everyone else who has self control Good for you guys
No but only cause the ice cream melts more than I like in the time it takes to eat the pint. I usually do half or 2/3
Honestly I haven’t eaten an entire pint in like fifteen years. If I’m buying a pint it’ll last like 4-6 servings. Buuuut if I go to an ice cream shop and they happen to give me a pint of ice cream as their double scoop… I can’t say I wouldn’t finish it on the spot
I heard that at the Ben and Jerry’s factory they tell you a pint is one serving size lol.
As opposed to what? So confused by your question.
I have before but I try not to make a habit of it. But I also won’t deny myself that either 😌
This flavor was so gross to me! The chocolate tasted like plastic chemical trash, this was sent right into the trash
The only time I haven’t been able to finish a pint was after finishing the first one
Its going down no questions asked lol
The only time I ever finished a whole pint was 8 months pregnant
Yes lol I always do and love this flavor too. Sometimes half. But usually the entire
Imma for real eat all of this flavor! 😋
I loveeeee this flavor but no never in one go
I ate an entire pint in one sitting twice in one week, then never again haha. I hated how bloated I felt the next day. But could I? Absolutely!
i usually eat 1/3 of it in one sitting. i’ve been really into having thee scoops of different ice creams, so they last longer that way too :]
I did once and threw up. but to be fair it was quart sized
Many times.
That’s more the norm than the exception. I’m also quite active, so that helps, ha!
Pretty much always in one sitting, yup
No but the first time I buy it there’s an excellent chance it will happen
It’s been a hot minute since I could house a whole pint of ice cream in one sitting. Makes my stomach hurt, and I usually get sick of the sweetness after about 1/3 of the pint anyways