7.4/10
The chocolate/peanut butter ice creams pair super well together, though the rich chocolate flavor sort of overpowers to more mild peanut butter flavored base. This is the most mix-in heavy ice cream I’ve ever had – Literally chunks in every single bite. So so many bits of cookie dough and tons of brownies. If you love mix ins then this pint is for you. The cookie dough tastes more like normal cookie dough and was not super peanut butter flavored. Overall the pint is not super peanut buttery which I was a little disappointed by. To be honest there were a little too many cookie dough chunks – I couldn’t isolate the ice cream even if I tried. Super rich, chewy, and yummy, but I’d opt for something else next time as my mind wasn’t blown. Have you had this flavor? What did you think?
by stratusnimbo
3 Comments
Good review, I am tracking about where you are.
I remember being fairly out on this one. I get the concept but don’t quite understand it being a standard flavor when they are/were so heavy on PB/Chocolate combos.
Just got the PB S’Mores flavor to try and hope to try this one next. Doesn’t sound as good as I was hoping but I still have to try it.
I like their OG half baked better