Please help me find this restaurant

Long shot here (and possibly against the rules, sorry if so).

I’m going insane trying to remember what restaurant I took my now wife to back in October of 2014. I am almost certain it had 1 Michelin star but can’t line up any pictures of the lists I’ve found. I also could have sworn it was in or around East Village or maybe NoHo.

The only things I can see on the menu are Monkeybread, Bucatini, Gnocchi, and Oysters.

Thanks!