I have a lot of experience cooking on a WSM but with a 2 year old and 8 month old I was looking into pellet grills as a time saver. Curious as to what you guys think of these.

https://www.samsclub.com/ip/Member-s-Mark-Pro-Series-36-Pellet-Smoker-with-Induction-Burner-and-Smoke-Tray/13930519749?classType=REGULAR&from=/search (this just went out of stock but would assume it will be back)

https://www.academy.com/p/grilla-silverbac-20-wood-pellet-grill (Currently $599 at Academy)

https://www.dickssportinggoods.com/p/camp-chef-woodwind-pro-36-22ccfuwdwndpr36plcfp/22ccfuwdwndpr36plcfp?sku=24241058&camp=CSE:DSG_2446732005048_lia_pla-2446732005048_187994872712_23178635464&segment=&gclsrc=aw.ds&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=23178635464&gbraid=0AAAAADv4bTayyI82vW2UM-NdZdWUHiJBk&gclid=Cj0KCQiAxonKBhC1ARIsAIHq_lszcOdYOifd7XtWgCh_Bxo0tdPfU6-xuaGAnPNKrrMUce0lPJ00YZkaAh-SEALw_wcB

Camp Chef is obviously the most expensive, is it worth the premium over the members mark pro series? They both have a smoke box, I have wireless thermometers that I can use already. I don't think I'll ever really use it as a grill, mostly as a smoker for brisket/ribs/pork shoulders/chicken/turkey. Leaning towards the members mark just because it seems like it gives most of what the camp chef does at a fraction of the price.

by USTS2020

4 Comments

  1. Galezilla

    Get the camp chef and don’t look back that’s a great deal

  2. Mecaneecall_Enjunear

    You’re comparing a Malibu and a Fusion (since quality is suspect) to a Mercedes. If your budget is more aligned with the Camp Chef, get it, but the other two are in a total different pricing segment.

  3. the_lost_carrot

    I’ve had the MM36 for two years now and it’s fantastic price for performance. Great features but it’s still a fairly budget smoker.

    The Camp Chef is going to be a significant step up. I’ve always said when the MM dies I’ll look into getting a serious upgrade. So you need to determine whether you have the money or want to spend it on a smoker or not

  4. RVAPGHTOM

    I have the 24 Camp Chef. Its been rock solid.