Dining and Cooking
Settle a debate. Is this too rare?
In Steak

Settle a debate. Is this too rare?

Wifey thinks I cook my steak too rare. All preference ofc, no judgment.

by Numerous_Cycle8043

26 Comments

  2. Biggreengolf

    Looks great to me. I cook it a bit more for my wife but I’d eat this all day.

  4. Lrcorndog610

    I mean in my opinion it could be cooked slightly more, but we’re talking maybe 30 seconds to a minute. Looks incredible.

  5. crazycatman206

    If you enjoyed eating it, it’s not too rare.

  7. snuggly_cobra

    First definitely was. Last pic not so much

  11. ihadtowalkhere

    If you made this for me and some one questioned it I would kick them out. Even if we were eating on an airplane.

  12. siddowncheelout

    First pic – yes

    Second and third pics – no

  13. twoscoopsofbacon

    Dude, didn’t notice the second and third pictures at first, and I still was leaning towards a “no – that looks close to fine but maybe needs a sear for taste”

  14. Entire_Toe2640

    Not too rare. Looks perfect. Delicious. I hope you had a nice Cabernet with it. Maybe a Malbec.

  15. dijon_bustard

    You are asking for an objective opinion on a strictly subjective matter.

  19. timdr18

    Looks medium rare to me, I personally like my ribeye medium but I sure as hell wouldn’t object if I was served this.

  25. tdaddy316420

    That crust and inside are godly.

    Time to get a new wife