Bit overhyped for me. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a really good bar burger overall, with the patty definitely being the highlight, but I also don’t see what’s so special about it? I’ve had much better. The fries were also kinda lame, and $32 is a bit silly. Thoughts?
by MovieMentor
35 Comments
Beautiful!
I gotta agree with you, OP. This honestly looks like a meal at fuckin’ Rollin’ Roaster. 😂
Almost $45 CAD for that is insane.
$32? What the fuck why
I’ve seen better burgers at a gas station
Potentially the most overhyped burger in the world. Thanks to Action Bronson’s insatiable need to sound cool/edgy.
Shake shack is better.
Looks terrible for the price, enjoy
I can’t believe anyone would spend $30 for this
I understand everything is more expensive in NY but $32 for that is ludicrous.
Looks good! But I’d pay half that price
I’m not gonna lie, that looks like a terrible burger. Looks like the shit I’d make in a nonstick pan with leftover 5 day old bottom shelf beef from Aldi back in college. Almost rubbery looking.
Looks very good, but $32? No.
$32 AND there’s enough ketchup there for about 3 of those coin fries. C’mon now
THIRTY TWO AMERICAN DOLLARS?!
I live in San Francisco so I get crazy pricing on hyped items but whew… I hope you still had a nice time out, OP.
I don’t know how that compares to other prices in NY, but that is an insane price where I live.
Plenty of burgers comparable to it in New York for half the price.
I hate those style “fries”
Looks unbelievably mid
Those potatoes look like they were rendered in Skyrim.
Wow. I mean the burger and fries look great to me but not at that price
Never would I pay that for a burger. It does look good though…….
I thought you were sounding a little harsh until I saw the price.
I mean you’re not going to necessarily see what’s so good about this burger from the photo, it’s the blend of dry aged meats that’s special.
That said, I have never been bc every time I’ve walked by there’s a line and I’m not going to make reservations to go to a place in red hook.
Also, EVERYTHING on the menu is that expensive so two people with a few drinks would be like 150 bucks w tax n tip, which is not worth it to me.
Luckily there’s a place 1 minute away called Brooklyn Ice House that does a good burger n fries for like 13 bucks (cash only!)
Lmao 🤣
It looks good, just not “$32 special” good.
Looks exceptionally average
I went there last week & the first thought after my first bite was very similar to you’re reaction. Kinda overhyped and very patty forward and a bit one dimensional. But I realized I still really enjoyed eating it and kinda liked the minimalist approach of making the patty the main attraction and have nothing stand in its way. Overall I think it’s a fantastic burger but it’s still far from my favorite. I personally prefer Emily by a lot. I do prefer it over au cheval though (which I found to be really overhyped).
Glad to know. It was on my list.
Damn, I’d rather have the big arch.
Hype burger price gouge
Those fries actually make me sad considering what you paid & the quality of beef.
EVERYTHING in New York is expensive.
Looks like the 10 dollar burger I get at the diner on Sundays
Ok I was just about to comment about how good that looked until I saw the price wtf??
I’d pay $64 for that burger. That is the best burger in NYC in my opinion.