my review / most to least favorite of protein pints. I can’t find the banana graham because there’s no kroger/etc stores in my state
- mint chip: very refreshing sweet mint and I thought the chips were a perfect size, added a nice crunch
- cookie dough: milky vanilla base, SO much cookie dough in the pint I was so surprised !
- cookies & cream: same nice milky vanilla base as the cookie dough. Cookie crumbles but no real big cookie chunks, nice flavor tho
- Salted caramel: not a salted caramel. Nice swirl thru the pint, flavor reminded me more of butterscotch tho
- strawberry: more of a strawberry milk flavor then fresh strawberry, very smooth
- coffee: cold brew + creamer flavor, smooth but a little boring
- Chocolate: flavor more of a dark chocolate? quite boring
- Peanut butter chip: quite disappointing. tasted like straight up whole milk with a hint of raw peanut flavor, not peanut butter
by Queasy_Dingo_8262
9 Comments
Just bought some of this, the cookie dough just has a kind of a weird aftertaste unfortunately
Cookie dough is a stable in my household. Probably go through a pint every few days.
As far as protein ice cream go these are number one for me. Excited to try the bluebell variety though.
Banana one is good! It’s not super peanut forward which I wish it was but it’s also not too artificial banana tasting either. Definitely doesn’t give laffy taffy, thank god.
I loved the peanut butter flavor! Excited to try more and I appreciate your comments on them!!!
thank you for your pictures and review!! i’ve been wondering about these. absolutely thrilled to know they’re good. how do they compare against Halo Top, if you’ve ever had it?
Cookies and Cream is amazing honestly it will be the only ice cream I eat for awhile.
Peanut butter chip is one of my favorites!
I’ve only had strawberry because it was on closeout. I ate 1 in one sitting (they’re light and I’m a big back on the inside) and got 2 more. Some of the points had QC issues (ice cream on outside of carton) so I took what was good and available. It took me much longer to go through the other 2 pints. Would recommend. Can’t wait to try some of the others, but they are pricey and for that price point i want gluttony lol
I’ve been looking for the cookie dough and banana. I am a big fan of Halo Top Mix-ins. Taste wise and for chunks to ice cream ratio, all the Mix-ins flavors are awesome imo, with the exception of the Cookie Dough one. It doesn’t have much cookie dough at all for some reason. I had to do a double take; thought I grabbed a non Mix-ins one by accident.