It’s 1 a.m. and students excitedly pour into Josiah’s, chatting after an evening of fun. Laughter bounces off the ivy-patterned walls as some pick up a burger. Others gravitate towards the drink and snack section, where they’ll grab a Vitamin Water or a box of cereal. For me, whether I come in looking for a sandwich and fries or a couple of snacks and a drink, I often end up using a meal swipe to pay, rather than wasting my precious Flex Points.

First-years and second-years living on campus are required to purchase a full coverage meal plan, which includes meal swipes and an allotted number of Flex Points — a dollar-per-point system. While we can use Flex Points to pay for snacks at Jo’s, the Ivy Room or the Blue Room, the most generous meal plan offers only $250 in Flex Points for the whole semester. Once these points run out, Brunonians can either pay out of pocket or use meal swipes — which can be  worth up to $27.62 — to pay for snacks, even if they simply want an apple or yogurt. To give Brunonians more agency in their dining experience, Brown should offer a full coverage dining plan composed mainly of Flex Points. 

Brown Dining has already assigned a monetary value to most dining hall purchases. Students that aren’t on the meal plan can pay $17.25 for breakfast, $22.50 for lunch and $26.25 dinner at the Sharpe Refectory or the Verney-Woolley Dining Hall, which both offer buffet-style selections. This means that third- and fourth-year students, who are not bound by a mandatory meal plan, are free to pay for what they want at Brown dining — they can use actual money to eat a full meal at a dining hall. It makes sense for first- and second-year students to have less flexibility than juniors and seniors: Young adults tend to have less confidence and experience managing money, and often regret their food spending choices.

Beyond just reducing pressure on students to manage money, a full coverage meal plan can help students navigate the challenging transition to college. As Brown asserts, an expansive meal plan can make it easier for new college students to maintain “health, well-being and academic excellence” without any concerns about their next meal. A full-coverage plan requires regular interaction at dining halls, which facilitates social connection. In addition, as food insecurity rates are high in college-aged populations, Brown has found comprehensive meal plans to be a helpful tool in solving this problem. When Brown started requiring a full-coverage meal plan for first-year students, food insecurity rates among first-years was lowest amongst all Brown undergraduates. The University is right in its idea that the newest students on College Hill could use guidance around food, but there’s no need for the University to prescribe the details of our dining.

Right now, first- and second-year students’ full-coverage meal plans consist primarily of allotted meal swipes. This makes sense for students who tend to dine at the Ratty or Andrews Commons, where a precious swipe goes to a well-proportioned hot meal. But it seems preposterous to equate the same swipe to a small pile of Chobani yogurts. A full-coverage meal plan costs between $4,121 and $4,377 per semester, which The Herald calculated as roughly working out to a cost-per-swipe between $12.96 and $21.54. Sometimes, I pop into Josiah’s with the desire for one Vitamin Water — surely that is not worth $12, let alone $20. But, with such limited Flex Points throughout the semester, meal swipes are often the best payment option. Worse yet, grabbing extra, unwanted food to reach a reasonable checkout valuation is wasteful — especially when many students lack the storage space to keep it fresh. Students shouldn’t have to decide between loading up on unwanted items to meet the full valuation of a meal swipe and using a meal swipe on two bottled beverages.

That’s why Brown should consider a full coverage meal plan offering more Flex Points. Doing so would give first- and second-year students greater flexibility, while providing them with helpful food guidance. Students could purchase one or two snacks without concerns about running out of weekly meal swipes or wasting swipes on cheaper items. With one of Brown’s full coverage meal plans allotting 20 swipes per week, students can easily run out of weekly swipes. More Flex Points would lessen this risk, making it less costly for students to pick up snacks throughout the day.

Such a dining plan structure has worked well for Boston College, where students’ dining cards operate on a “declining balance system” similar to that of a debit card.  An investment of just over $3,000 per semester affords students 3,000 dining dollars to use at most of BC’s dining locations, pop-up events and the campus’ Farmer’s Market. The lightest plan grants students approximately $31 per day to spend on any food they please. This gives students the flexibility of eating what they want and when they want, without the need to consider the raw cost of their items as compared to the value of each meal swipe. 

Boston College’s meal plan is radically dollar-focused — Brown doesn’t have to take on such a dining dollar-oriented approach to address wasteful swipes. This would be an unnecessarily major deviation from Brown’s current dining pricing, and our problems could be addressed with the more minor tweak of a Flex-oriented full coverage meal plan. I cannot count how many times I’ve restrained myself at Josiah’s out of a desire to save my meal swipes for bigger meals. The implementation of such a plan would be simple. If a first- or second-year student knows they prefer lighter meals or snacks, they can select a Flex Point-dominated dining plan. 

Brown is one of the most expensive schools in the country. If the University is going to require its students to pay thousands of dollars to eat, it might as well let them eat as they like. 

Anya Kleinman ’30 can be reached at anya_kleinman@brown.edu. Please send responses to this column to letters@browndailyherald.com and other opinions to opinions@browndailyherald.com.

Dining and Cooking