Disclaimer, I’m not a bagel connoisseur so take my opinion lightly. My other go to is the #4 at Bagel Pub.

by LeftReflection6620

14 Comments

  1. LeftReflection6620

    Pastrami egg and cheese is usually the go to here but had to switch it up to not feel like a Gordito

  2. CactusBoyScout

    You’re not far from the source of the lox at that point. Acme’s factory is in Greenpoint. You can buy directly from the factory on Friday mornings.

  3. why_squ1rtle

    bagels r so hit or miss in nyc. its only good if u get it fresh imo. if its been sitting longer than 30 min ill ask for a toast. ideally its fresh made for u.

    i much prefer the taste of fluffy bagel out the oven instead of one sitting around but sometimes i’ll ask n they’ll be like ya its kinda fresh but then i bite and its hard as a rock.

    idk where ur based but u should give baz bagel on grand a try. sometimes they will make it fresh. ive been there like 4 times recently n ive had a freshie like half the time. but the freshie is amazing though.

    i know i sound like a spoiled piglet but whatevs oink oink

    edit: idk whats up w the downvotes but yall r missing out if u just only eat stale bagels

  4. originalcondition

    $16.50?! it makes sense because nice fish, but damn i hate being so broke :s

  5. rmpbklyn

    you mean smoked or lox. pastrami is not fish

  6. Anonymoustard

    That is nothing like what I order and I think it’s fantastic. Enjoy!!!

  7. JustBlazedNYC

    The bagels are hard and, frankly, ass.

  8. herseyhawkins33

    a little light on the cream cheese but otherwise looks delicious!

  9. Bagels here can be sus. But I had this exact thing the other day with a decent bagel and it was wonderful.

  10. defcon1000

    Frankel’s is up it’s own ass.

    Go to the website and the first menu option is “SHOP MERCH”, followed by the hours and -finally- a menu. If the place was truly legit they’d bank on their food and not their name.

    Overpriced, over-hyped and underwhelming.

    Walk just one block north to Bagel Point and get double the sandwich for less money (and a better bagel tbh).

Write A Comment