I have 26 different Van Leeuwen’s flavors in my freezer and I’ll be testing one by one. #17/26 – Cookie Butter

9.1/10 – Yes!! We finally have it. A sweet ice cream that isn’t overly sweet, add ins that aren’t dry, and nothing is super overpowering. The brown sugar is a little overpowering, but not by much. The base ice cream is so good. THEN YOU HIT THAT SWIRL. Oh my gosh, it is very good. My wife makes me oatmeal cookies often and this remains me of that batter so much. My only teeny tiny complaint is that I wish the add in chunks were a little bit bigger. Do yourself a favor and buy every single of these next time you see it in the store!