A few weeks ago, I ordered two pecan pie pints because I knew they were going to stop being sold. I threw the bag in the freezer without looking inside… until last night I went to pull out one of the pecan pie pints. Surprise surprise! It was marshmallow sky!!!! I’ve been searching with no luck and here they were in my freezer the whole time!
To my disappointment though, it doesn’t taste as good as I’d hoped 😭 to me, the ice cream itself doesn’t have any flavor?? I don’t taste any marshmallow! But I do love the big chunks of cookie dough and brownies! Maybe my pint is just not as strong or my tastebuds are off
by nutterfluffs
6 Comments
A pie in the sky? Who knew!
That really sucks, but hopefully they can replace it for you still! I wasn’t crazy about Marshmallow Sky either. It was alright, but I wouldn’t buy it again. I felt exactly how you did about it; the ice cream part wasn’t really my thing.
Marshmallow is my favorite flavor, and I also didn’t care for this ice cream! I had a scoop at one of their physical locations, so I havent bothered trying to find the pints.
Hopefully you can get your pie!
I didn’t enjoy this flavor that much either! I agree that it was pretty flavorless!
if i isolate some of the swirl on my spoon, i can almost taste marshmallow lmao. but i’m in it for the cookie dough, so i don’t mind. btw there’s no brownies in this, it’s chocolate cookie dough 🙂
Marshmallow sky is so overrated. I’m with you. Wasn’t impressed, wouldn’t buy it again. Didn’t even finish the pint.