The first comment I got on my haul yesterday asked for the burnt orange dreamsicle to be reviewed first!
7.5/10 – I’m close to giving this an 8/10, but there’s something keeping me from it. I’m a huge fan of orange creamsicles, and this pint puts a fun twist on a classic flavor. The orange swirl is very refreshing and sweet like a fresh orange slice, the vanilla custard swirl is smooth and creamy but I don’t get the strongest vanilla bean flavor. The burnt orange swirl is a little hard to find and I had to dig through the top to get to it, but once you get a bite, you’re hit with a slightly salty, rich orange and caramel flavor. I actually think the caramel is what throws the flavors off for me. Usually, I’m a huge fan of caramel swirls, but this doesn’t seem to fit the flavor profiles. All together, there’s an off putting tang, like if an orange was placed in a hot skillet and someone spilled milk on top of it.
I guess that’s where the burnt flavor comes from 😂
by nutterfluffs
3 Comments
Its all about that Brambleberry one!
this is a great review, i am super excited to try this. finding this sub was a mistake for my bank account. i saw yall buying $10 pints and thought you were crazy… then i tried them and i am hooked.
I had this for the first time last night! I think I’d give it a similar rating. I wanted a bit more of that classic creamsicle flavor and the orange rind from the caramel was just a smidge too bitter.
It was almost like an orange cream pop dipped in aperol. Good but not what I was expecting.