Canal House Station has been one of the state’s most acclaimed restaurants since it opened in 2019. Owners Melissa Hamilton and Christopher Hirsheimer have been nominated for multiple James Beard Awards during their time at the helm in Milford, and previously won one for their 2013 cook book, “Canal House Cooks Every Day.”

But despite that acclaim, the restaurant situated in what was once a train station will soon close its doors.

Hamilton and Hirsheimer sent an email to customers Wednesday announcing the restaurant will be closing in December so the duo can focus on cookbooks.

“We wanted to let you know that we will hang up our aprons, walk away from our stoves, and head back to our desks at the end of this year to return to our Canal House Cooking writing and publishing projects.,” the email said. “Canal House Station will close after our last Sunday Dinner on December 21, 2025.”

Ownership told NJ Advance Media in a recent rave review the goal of the restaurant was to share their cooking and author process with guests. But reached on Thursday, Hamilton and Hirsheimer said juggling both writing and a restaurant was simply too much for the pair.

“We’ve had some books on hold since we started the restaurant and it’s impossible to write books when you’re running a restaurant,” Hamilton said. “We’ve been thinking about it, but it’s never been a firm thought until it kind of presented itself recently.”

Owners Christopher Hirsheimer (Left) and Melissa Hamilton (Right) of Canal House Station in Milford, NJOwners Christopher Hirsheimer (Left) and Melissa Hamilton (Right) of Canal House Station in Milford, NJ (Credit: Canal House)Canal House

The pair has already rented a new private studio, away from the transformed abandoned train station they turned into one of the state’s best restaurants. The duo was named a James Beard Award semifinalist for best chef in the mid-Atlantic region in 2020 and 2022. The restaurant was also featured on USA Today’s best restaurants list for 2025.

While the last chance to eat at Canal House Station will be on Dec. 21, Hamilton and Hirsheimer wouldn’t close the door on hosting other hands-on culinary experiences.

“We hadn’t thought about pop-ups. It might be hard to not do pop-ups, we probably will,” Hamilton said. “ We’ve rented beautiful parks or someone has loaned us their meadow or barn (in the past). It’s not out of the question.”

If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

Dining and Cooking