I also added my own touch, by making their expressions correlate to how many teddies they received.
While it tasted like your typical sugar cookie, everyone that I gave them to said they were adorable!
Next time, I’m going to make some icing and give them some pants.
Feel free to post any suggestions that you may have.
ceciem2100
This inspired me to finally buy food colouring pens for fine details like faces! I needed something to push me over the edge, I’ve been wanting to since I saw another post using them!
tinaxcochina
Everything is Punch the monkey coded for me right now, but they are very adorable! 🥹♥️
ConcreteKeys
That’s funny that there is a distinction in smiles with the one and two bears.
Jamesie7
LOVE 🥰🥰🥰
Gohan1fangirl
Heck yeah you did. You’re loving and owning it.
Jess_sunshinydays
These are so adorable 😍
huntsber
Some have two and some have none this world is truly unfair I cant
jjumbuck
Super cute! I made them for xmas and loved how they looked but the flavour was a bit meh to me. I also used the bears! I love your different faces. 🙂
Frosty-Cap3344
Ok, I need to make these, they look so cool
olkaad
What’s used for the face?
jolizzyro
I’m by no means good at baking (outside of chocolate chip cookies and banana bread) but I love this sub for all of the fun creations you guys make! Maybe one day I’ll be bold and attempt something that I see here
BucketBakes
I am absolutely stealing this idea; 10/10 love them. Great job!
ChitChatWithCats
Ok where do you get chocolate teddy grahams. I haven’t been able to find them (Canada) in probably over 15 years 😭😭😭
Sunflowerbook
It’s giving Panchi 😭 … the idea is so cute! These made me giggle
Enna_Owens
They look delicious!
Current-Breath-7728
O my god soo cute…🥰
karkardagi
I love the stars holding the bears! So cute!
FarmAnt2025
OMG these are the CUTEST!!!!!!!!!!
xspineofasnakex
The sad stars 😭 so cute!
wocka-jocka-blocka
Anybody know if you could use pre-made edible sugar icing decorations for cupcakes, etc. (like the 12 packs of santa faces or christmas trees) with this idea? Make the stars hold little christmas presents or something? I get why the Teddy Grahams work; they don’t melt. But just questioning if 8 mins of baking time would melt a sugar icing decoration before the sugar cookie was done … Any thoughts?
Low_Insurance5329
These would be too cute for a baby shower or celebrating someone graduating as a baby nurse (I can’t remember the term rn lol)
24 Comments
The sad stars are making me sad. Give them a bear!
omgggg this is SOO cute!! the poor sad stars </3
When I first saw [this post](https://www.reddit.com/r/Baking/comments/1pqndi0/this_sub_inspired_me_to_make_the_cutest_cookies/), I knew I absolutely had to give it a shot.
I used [Sally’s recipe](https://sallysbakingaddiction.com/best-sugar-cookies/) for sugar cookies, and used Treddy Graham.
I also added my own touch, by making their expressions correlate to how many teddies they received.
While it tasted like your typical sugar cookie, everyone that I gave them to said they were adorable!
Next time, I’m going to make some icing and give them some pants.
Feel free to post any suggestions that you may have.
This inspired me to finally buy food colouring pens for fine details like faces! I needed something to push me over the edge, I’ve been wanting to since I saw another post using them!
Everything is Punch the monkey coded for me right now, but they are very adorable! 🥹♥️
That’s funny that there is a distinction in smiles with the one and two bears.
LOVE 🥰🥰🥰
Heck yeah you did. You’re loving and owning it.
These are so adorable 😍
Some have two and some have none this world is truly unfair I cant
Super cute! I made them for xmas and loved how they looked but the flavour was a bit meh to me. I also used the bears! I love your different faces. 🙂
Ok, I need to make these, they look so cool
What’s used for the face?
I’m by no means good at baking (outside of chocolate chip cookies and banana bread) but I love this sub for all of the fun creations you guys make! Maybe one day I’ll be bold and attempt something that I see here
I am absolutely stealing this idea; 10/10 love them. Great job!
Ok where do you get chocolate teddy grahams. I haven’t been able to find them (Canada) in probably over 15 years 😭😭😭
It’s giving Panchi 😭 … the idea is so cute! These made me giggle
They look delicious!
O my god soo cute…🥰
I love the stars holding the bears! So cute!
OMG these are the CUTEST!!!!!!!!!!
The sad stars 😭 so cute!
Anybody know if you could use pre-made edible sugar icing decorations for cupcakes, etc. (like the 12 packs of santa faces or christmas trees) with this idea? Make the stars hold little christmas presents or something? I get why the Teddy Grahams work; they don’t melt. But just questioning if 8 mins of baking time would melt a sugar icing decoration before the sugar cookie was done … Any thoughts?
These would be too cute for a baby shower or celebrating someone graduating as a baby nurse (I can’t remember the term rn lol)